GNNs Getting ComFy: Community and Feature Similarity Guided Rewiring
Celia Rubio-Madrigal, Adarsh Jamadandi, Rebekka Burkholz

TL;DR
This paper introduces three novel graph rewiring strategies, including a hybrid approach, to improve GNN performance by enhancing community structure and feature similarity, supported by theoretical analysis and extensive experiments.
Contribution
It proposes new rewiring methods that explicitly target community and feature similarity, offering computational efficiency and improved GNN generalization.
Findings
ComFy outperforms spectral gap optimization in experiments.
Community-aware rewiring improves label-community alignment.
Feature similarity rewiring increases global homophily.
Abstract
Maximizing the spectral gap through graph rewiring has been proposed to enhance the performance of message-passing graph neural networks (GNNs) by addressing over-squashing. However, as we show, minimizing the spectral gap can also improve generalization. To explain this, we analyze how rewiring can benefit GNNs within the context of stochastic block models. Since spectral gap optimization primarily influences community strength, it improves performance when the community structure aligns with node labels. Building on this insight, we propose three distinct rewiring strategies that explicitly target community structure, node labels, and their alignment: (a) community structure-based rewiring (ComMa), a more computationally efficient alternative to spectral gap optimization that achieves similar goals; (b) feature similarity-based rewiring (FeaSt), which focuses on maximizing global…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
The extensive experimental results.
Thm. 1 seems to be very incremental; in which part do the authors claim the result is novel? The second eigenvalue of the Laplacian of the expected SMB is almost folklore. Right below the Thm.1, the authors claim as follows; " increasing q and decreasing p increases the spectral gap but makes the community structure less pronounced, and vice versa" However, if we believe that the spectral gap is proportional to q-p/q+p, the gap is larger when p=0.3 and q=0.0001 than when p=0.9 and q=0.1. Howev
- Good theoretical motivation through planted partition model. - Extensive experiments on many benchmark datasets show the methods efficacy against the competition.
- Comfy is actually missing from the main text - not only the algorithm but also a textual explanation is very lacking. - Planted partition model with only 2 communities is very simple and does not reflect real-world datasets. - The elected competitors are highly related to the proposed method. A More diverse competition would be beneficial.
(1) The author established a systematic theoretical framework through the Random Block Model and analyzed the impact of community strength and graph task alignment on GNN performance. To some extent this paper enriched relevant theoretical research. (2) The proposed FeaSt and ComFy integrate feature similarity into graph rewiring methods, exploring how to optimize the performance of GNN by considering node features. (3) In addition to theoretical analysis, the paper also demonstrated the perfor
(1) The article is mainly based on the Random Block Model (SBM) for theoretical analysis, but real-world graph data often has more complex structures and dynamic changes, and the assumptions of SBM may not fully capture these complexities. (2) The method proposed in the article does not clearly explain and analyze the impact of adding or removing edges on model performance. (3) The article did not discuss in detail how the proposed rewiring strategy performs in situations where the community str
Code & Models
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsTopic Modeling
