How Does Microservice Granularity Impact Energy Consumption and Performance? A Controlled Experiment

TL;DR

This study investigates how the level of microservice granularity affects energy consumption and performance, revealing significant impacts and complex interactions that inform better microservice design decisions.

Contribution

It provides the first controlled experimental analysis of microservice granularity's effects on energy and performance across different system scales.

Findings

Finer granularity increases energy consumption and response time.

Higher request loads significantly raise energy use and response times.

System scale influences the relationship between granularity, energy, and performance.

Abstract

Context: Microservice architectures are a widely used software deployment approach, with benefits regarding flexibility and scalability. However, their impact on energy consumption is poorly understood, and often overlooked in favor of performance and other quality attributes (QAs). One understudied concept in this area is microservice granularity, i.e., over how many services the system functionality is distributed. Objective: We therefore aim to analyze the relationship between microservice granularity and two critical QAs in microservice-based systems: energy consumption and performance. Method: We conducted a controlled experiment using two open-source microservice-based systems of different scales: the small Pet Clinic system and the large Train Ticket system. For each system, we created three levels of granularity by merging or splitting services (coarse, medium, and fine) and then exposed them to five levels of request frequency. Results: Our findings revealed that: i) granularity significantly affected both energy consumption and response time, e.g., in the large system, fine granularity consumed on average 461 J more energy (13%) and added 5.2 ms to response time (14%) compared to coarse granularity; ii) higher request loads significantly increased both energy consumption and response times, with moving from 40 to 400 requests / s resulting in 651 J higher energy consumption (23%) and 41.2 ms longer response times (98%); iii) there is a complex relationship between granularity, system scale, energy consumption, and performance that warrants careful consideration in microservice design. We derive generalizable takeaways from our results. Conclusion: Microservices practitioners should take our findings into account when making granularity-related decisions, especially for large-scale systems.