Generative AI as a Playful yet Offensive Tourist: Exploring Tensions Between Playful Features and Citizen Concerns in Designing Urban Play

TL;DR

This paper explores how generative AI can support playful urban experiences while addressing citizen concerns, through design tools and participatory evaluation, highlighting both opportunities and challenges in urban AI integration.

Contribution

It introduces iWonder, a generative AI tool for urban design, and provides insights into balancing playful features with citizen concerns in city environments.

Findings

GAI enables playful urban interactions through generative agency and unpredictability.

Citizen evaluations reveal concerns about offensive qualities and social implications.

Design considerations can mitigate risks and enhance GAI's urban impact.

Abstract

Play is pivotal in fostering the emotional, social, and cultural dimensions of urban spaces. While generative AI (GAI) potentially supports playful urban interaction, a balanced and critical approach to the design opportunities and challenges is needed. This work develops iWonder, an image-to-image GAI tool engaging fourteen designers in urban explorations to identify GAI's playful features and create design ideas. Fourteen citizens then evaluated these ideas, providing expectations and critical concerns from a bottom-up perspective. Our findings reveal the dynamic interplay between users, GAI, and urban contexts, highlighting GAI's potential to facilitate playful urban experiences through generative agency, meaningful unpredictability, social performativity, and the associated offensive qualities. We propose design considerations to address citizen concerns and the `tourist metaphor' to deepen our understanding of GAI's impact, offering insights to enhance cities' socio-cultural fabric. Overall, this research contributes to the effort to harness GAI's capabilities for urban enrichment.