Assessing the Impact of Sampling Irregularity in Time Series Data: Human Activity Recognition As A Case Study

TL;DR

This paper investigates how irregular sampling affects human activity recognition models, finding that current neural networks are largely unaffected and highlighting the need for new approaches to handle sampling irregularities.

Contribution

The study systematically evaluates the impact of sampling irregularities on HAR models and reveals limitations of existing neural networks in addressing these challenges.

Findings

Timestamp variations do not significantly impact model performance.

Continuous-time neural networks are ineffective against irregular sampling.

Highlighting the need for new models to handle sampling irregularity.

Abstract

Human activity recognition (HAR) ideally relies on data from wearable or environment-instrumented sensors sampled at regular intervals, enabling standard neural network models optimized for consistent time-series data as input. However, real-world sensor data often exhibits irregular sampling due to, for example, hardware constraints, power-saving measures, or communication delays, posing challenges for deployed static HAR models. This study assesses the impact of sampling irregularities on HAR by simulating irregular data through two methods: introducing slight inconsistencies in sampling intervals (timestamp variations) to mimic sensor jitter, and randomly removing data points (random dropout) to simulate missing values due to packet loss or sensor failure. We evaluate both discrete-time neural networks and continuous-time neural networks, which are designed to handle continuous-time data, on three public datasets. We demonstrate that timestamp variations do not significantly affect the performance of discrete-time neural networks, and the continuous-time neural network is also ineffective in addressing the challenges posed by irregular sampling, possibly due to limitations in modeling complex temporal patterns with missing data. Our findings underscore the necessity for new models or approaches that can robustly handle sampling irregularity in time-series data, like the reading in human activity recognition, paving the way for future research in this domain.