Targeted incentives for social tipping in heterogeneous networked populations

TL;DR

This paper develops a game-theoretic model to optimize targeted incentives for social tipping in diverse networks, considering constraints like cost and influence, to effectively promote societal behavioral change.

Contribution

It introduces a novel framework incorporating heterogeneity and local influence networks to analyze and optimize intervention strategies for social tipping.

Findings

Trade-off between preventing backsliding and promoting change.

Cost-optimal strategies depend on resistance and heterogeneity.

Targeting influence varies with network properties and intervention goals.

Abstract

Many societal challenges, such as climate change or disease outbreaks, require coordinated behavioral changes. For many behaviors, the tendency of individuals to adhere to social norms can reinforce the status quo. However, these same social processes can also result in rapid, self-reinforcing change. Interventions may be strategically targeted to initiate endogenous social change processes, often referred to as social tipping. While recent research has considered how the size and targeting of such interventions impact their effectiveness at bringing about change, they tend to overlook constraints faced by policymakers, including the cost, speed, and distributional consequences of interventions. To address this complexity, we introduce a game-theoretic framework that includes heterogeneous agents and networks of local influence. We implement various targeting heuristics based on information about individual preferences and commonly used local network properties to identify individuals to incentivize. Analytical and simulation results suggest that there is a trade-off between preventing backsliding among targeted individuals and promoting change among non-targeted individuals. Thus, where the change is initiated in the population and the direction in which it propagates is essential to the effectiveness of interventions. We identify cost-optimal strategies under different scenarios, such as varying levels of resistance to change, preference heterogeneity, and homophily. These results provide insights that can be experimentally tested and help policymakers to better direct incentives.