Improving Figures of Merit for Quantum Circuit Compilation

TL;DR

This paper investigates the correlation between traditional figures of merit and actual quantum circuit execution quality, revealing weaknesses and proposing a machine learning-based figure of merit that better predicts real performance.

Contribution

It introduces a novel machine learning-based figure of merit that more accurately predicts quantum circuit execution quality on real hardware.

Findings

Weak correlation between existing figures of merit and actual performance

Complex figures of merit do not necessarily improve prediction accuracy

The proposed machine learning approach achieves a 49% average correlation improvement

Abstract

Quantum computing is an emerging technology that has seen significant software and hardware improvements in recent years. Executing a quantum program requires the compilation of its quantum circuit for a target Quantum Processing Unit (QPU). Various methods for qubit mapping, gate synthesis, and optimization of quantum circuits have been proposed and implemented in compilers. These compilers try to generate a quantum circuit that leads to the best execution quality - a criterion that is usually approximated by figures of merit such as the number of (two-qubit) gates, the circuit depth, expected fidelity, or estimated success probability. However, it is often unclear how well these figures of merit represent the actual execution quality on a QPU. In this work, we investigate the correlation between established figures of merit and actual execution quality on real machines - revealing that the correlation is weaker than anticipated and that more complex figures of merit are not necessarily more accurate. Motivated by this finding, we propose an improved figure of merit (based on a machine learning approach) that can be used to predict the expected execution quality of a quantum circuit for a chosen QPU without actually executing it. The employed machine learning model reveals the influence of various circuit features on generating high correlation scores. The proposed figure of merit demonstrates a strong correlation and outperforms all previous ones in a case study - achieving an average correlation improvement of 49%.