On the Energy Consumption of Test Generation

TL;DR

This study investigates the energy consumption of automated test generation with EvoSuite, revealing that different algorithms and manual tests vary in energy use, with implications for optimizing testing efficiency.

Contribution

It provides the first empirical analysis of energy consumption in automated test generation, comparing different algorithms and manual testing in Java programs.

Findings

Different test generation algorithms consume varying energy levels.

Manual tests often use more energy than automated tests.

High complexity classes lead to higher energy consumption.

Abstract

Research in the area of automated test generation has seen remarkable progress in recent years, resulting in several approaches and tools for effective and efficient generation of test cases. In particular, the EvoSuite tool has been at the forefront of this progress embodying various algorithms for automated test generation of Java programs. EvoSuite has been used to generate test cases for a wide variety of programs as well. While there are a number of empirical studies that report results on the effectiveness, in terms of code coverage and other related metrics, of the various test generation strategies and algorithms implemented in EvoSuite, there are no studies, to the best of our knowledge, on the energy consumption associated to the automated test generation. In this paper, we set out to investigate this aspect by measuring the energy consumed by EvoSuite when generating tests. We also measure the energy consumed in the execution of the test cases generated, comparing them with those manually written by developers. The results show that the different test generation algorithms consumed different amounts of energy, in particular on classes with high cyclomatic complexity. Furthermore, we also observe that manual tests tend to consume more energy as compared to automatically generated tests, without necessarily achieving higher code coverage. Our results also give insight into the methods that consume significantly higher levels of energy, indicating potential points of improvement both for EvoSuite as well as the different programs under test.