Beating Competitive Ratio 4 for Graphic Matroid Secretary

TL;DR

This paper advances the graphic matroid secretary problem by developing an algorithm with a competitive ratio of 3.95, improving previous bounds, and demonstrates ratios approaching e for graphs with large girth, supporting the strong matroid secretary conjecture.

Contribution

It introduces a new algorithm surpassing the 4-competitive barrier, achieving a ratio of 3.95, and shows ratios close to e are possible for graphs with large girth, providing evidence for the strong conjecture.

Findings

New algorithm with ratio 3.95 for graphic matroids.

Improved ratio to 3.77 for simple graphs.

Ratios arbitrarily close to e for graphs with large girth.

Abstract

One of the classic problems in online decision-making is the *secretary problem* where to goal is to maximize the probability of choosing the largest number from a randomly ordered sequence. A natural extension allows selecting multiple values under a combinatorial constraint. Babaioff, Immorlica, Kempe, and Kleinberg (SODA'07, JACM'18) introduced the *matroid secretary conjecture*, suggesting an $O(1)$-competitive algorithm exists for matroids. Many works since have attempted to obtain algorithms for both general matroids and specific classes of matroids. The ultimate goal is to obtain an $e$-competitive algorithm, and the *strong matroid secretary conjecture* states that this is possible for general matroids. A key class of matroids is the *graphic matroid*, where a set of graph edges is independent if it contains no cycle. The rich combinatorial structure of graphs makes them a natural first step towards solving a problem for general matroids. Babaioff et al. (SODA'07, JACM'18) first studied the graphic matroid setting, achieving a $16$-competitive algorithm. Subsequent works have improved the competitive ratio, most recently to 4 by Soto, Turkieltaub, and Verdugo (SODA'18). We break this $4$-competitive barrier, presenting a new algorithm with a competitive ratio of $3.95$. For simple graphs, we further improve this to $3.77$. Intuitively, solving the problem for simple graphs is easier since they lack length-two cycles. A natural question is whether a ratio arbitrarily close to $e$ can be achieved by assuming sufficiently large girth. We answer this affirmatively, showing a competitive ratio arbitrarily close to $e$ even for constant girth values, supporting the strong matroid secretary conjecture. We also prove this bound is tight: for any constant $g$, no algorithm can achieve a ratio better than $e$ even when the graph has girth at least $g$.