Towards Best Practices for Open Datasets for LLM Training

TL;DR

This paper discusses the legal, technical, and sociological challenges of creating open datasets for training large language models, emphasizing the need for collaboration and standards to promote transparency and responsible AI development.

Contribution

It highlights the barriers to assembling large open datasets and proposes a multidisciplinary approach to foster open, responsibly curated data for LLM training.

Findings

Legal and technical challenges hinder open dataset creation

Metadata and digitization issues complicate dataset assembly

Collaborative efforts are essential for responsible data governance

Abstract

Many AI companies are training their large language models (LLMs) on data without the permission of the copyright owners. The permissibility of doing so varies by jurisdiction: in countries like the EU and Japan, this is allowed under certain restrictions, while in the United States, the legal landscape is more ambiguous. Regardless of the legal status, concerns from creative producers have led to several high-profile copyright lawsuits, and the threat of litigation is commonly cited as a reason for the recent trend towards minimizing the information shared about training datasets by both corporate and public interest actors. This trend in limiting data information causes harm by hindering transparency, accountability, and innovation in the broader ecosystem by denying researchers, auditors, and impacted individuals access to the information needed to understand AI models. While this could be mitigated by training language models on open access and public domain data, at the time of writing, there are no such models (trained at a meaningful scale) due to the substantial technical and sociological challenges in assembling the necessary corpus. These challenges include incomplete and unreliable metadata, the cost and complexity of digitizing physical records, and the diverse set of legal and technical skills required to ensure relevance and responsibility in a quickly changing landscape. Building towards a future where AI systems can be trained on openly licensed data that is responsibly curated and governed requires collaboration across legal, technical, and policy domains, along with investments in metadata standards, digitization, and fostering a culture of openness.