Consistency of Responses and Continuations Generated by Large Language Models on Social Media

TL;DR

This study examines how large language models generate emotionally consistent and semantically coherent responses on social media, revealing their tendency to moderate negative emotions and maintain high semantic similarity.

Contribution

It provides new insights into the emotional and semantic behaviors of LLMs in social media contexts, comparing multiple models and human content.

Findings

Models tend to neutralize negative emotions in responses.

High semantic coherence is maintained across models.

Models prefer neutral or positive emotional tones in social media responses.

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable capabilities in text generation, yet their emotional consistency and semantic coherence in social media contexts remain insufficiently understood. This study investigates how LLMs handle emotional content and maintain semantic relationships through continuation and response tasks using three open-source models: Gemma, Llama3 and Llama3.3 and one commercial Model:Claude. By analyzing climate change discussions from Twitter and Reddit, we examine emotional transitions, intensity patterns, and semantic consistency between human-authored and LLM-generated content. Our findings reveal that while both models maintain high semantic coherence, they exhibit distinct emotional patterns: these models show a strong tendency to moderate negative emotions. When the input text carries negative emotions such as anger, disgust, fear, or sadness, LLM tends to generate content with more neutral emotions, or even convert them into positive emotions such as joy or surprise. At the same time, we compared the LLM-generated content with human-authored content. The four models systematically generated responses with reduced emotional intensity and showed a preference for neutral rational emotions in the response task. In addition, these models all maintained a high semantic similarity with the original text, although their performance in the continuation task and the response task was different. These findings provide deep insights into the emotion and semantic processing capabilities of LLM, which are of great significance for its deployment in social media environments and human-computer interaction design.