How Large is the Universe of RNA-Like Motifs? A Clustering Analysis of RNA Graph Motifs Using Topological Descriptors

TL;DR

This study uses topological descriptors and clustering algorithms to estimate the diversity and size of RNA-like graph motifs, identifying potential new RNA structures from a large set of possible graph topologies.

Contribution

Introduces a novel computational topology-based method with machine learning to classify RNA-like graph motifs and estimate the universe of possible RNA structures.

Findings

97.3% of known RNA graphs are correctly clustered as RNA-like

Approximately 46% of hypothetical graphs are predicted to be RNA-like

Topological features distinguish RNA-like from non-RNA-like graphs

Abstract

We introduce a computational topology-based approach with unsupervised machine-learning algorithms to estimate the database size and content of RNA-like graph topologies. Specifically, we apply graph theory enumeration to generate all 110,667 possible 2D dual graphs for vertex numbers ranging from 2 to 9. Among them, only 0.11% graphs correspond to approximately 200,000 known RNA atomic fragments (collected in 2021) using the RNA-as-Graphs (RAG) mapping method. The remaining 99.89% of the dual graphs may be RNA-like or non-RNA-like. To determine which dual graphs in the 99.89% hypothetical set are more likely to be associated with RNA structures, we apply computational topology descriptors using the Persistent Spectral Graphs (PSG) method to characterize each graph using 19 PSG-based features and use clustering algorithms that partition all possible dual graphs into two clusters, RNA-like cluster and non-RNA-like cluster. The distance of each dual graph to the center of the RNA-like cluster represents the likelihood of it belonging to RNA structures. From validation, our PSG-based RNA-like cluster includes 97.3% of the 121 known RNA dual graphs, suggesting good performance. Furthermore, 46.017% of the hypothetical RNAs are predicted to be RNA-like. Significantly, we observe that all the top 15 RNA-like dual graphs can be separated into multiple subgraphs, whereas the top 15 non-RNA-like dual graphs tend not to have any subgraphs. Moreover, a significant topological difference between top RNA-like and non-RNA-like graphs is evident when comparing their topological features. These findings provide valuable insights into the size of the RNA motif universe and RNA design strategies, offering a novel framework for predicting RNA graph topologies and guiding the discovery of novel RNA motifs, perhaps anti-viral therapeutics by subgraph assembly.