Detecting Turbulent Patterns in Particulate Pipe Flow by Streak Angle Visualization

TL;DR

This paper introduces a low-cost, robust streak visualization method for detecting flow regime transitions in particulate pipe flows, validated against established techniques and effective at low particle concentrations.

Contribution

The study presents a novel, simple streak visualization technique that accurately identifies flow regimes and critical Reynolds numbers in particulate pipe flows, especially at low particle concentrations.

Findings

Effective in differentiating flow regimes using streak angles.

Accurately identifies critical Reynolds number with statistical analysis.

Validates method against PIV and pressure measurements.

Abstract

Detecting the transition from laminar to turbulent flow in particulate pipe systems remains a complex issue in fluid dynamics, often requiring sophisticated and costly experimental apparatus. This research presents an innovative streak visualization method designed to offer a simple and robust approach to identify transitional turbulent patterns in particulate pipe flows with neutrally buoyant particles. The technique employs a laser arrangement and a low-cost camera setup to capture particle-generated streaks within the fluid, enabling real-time observation of flow patterns. Validation of the proposed method was conducted through comparison with established techniques like Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) and pressure drop measurements, confirming its accuracy and reliability. Experiments demonstrate the streak visualization method's capacity to differentiate between laminar, transitional, and turbulent flow regimes by analyzing the standard deviation of streak angles. The method is especially efficient at low particle concentration, ie precisely where other more established methods become less effective. Furthermore, this technique enables us to identify a critical Reynolds number using Kullback-Leibler divergence built on the statistical distribution of streak angles, which is consistent with previous studies. Because it is effective at low concentrations and robust, this streak visualization technique opens new perspectives for the characterization of particulate pipe flows not only in the confines of the laboratory but also in less controlled industrial multi-phase flows where determining the laminar or turbulent nature of the flow is a prerequisite for flowmeter calibration.