Aligning Large Language Models for Faithful Integrity Against Opposing Argument

TL;DR

This paper introduces AFICE, a framework that improves large language models' ability to maintain faithful and trustworthy responses during conversations by estimating response confidence and aligning responses with faithful statements.

Contribution

The paper proposes a novel confidence estimation method and a training framework to enhance LLMs' fidelity and trustworthiness against opposing arguments.

Findings

Significant improvement in maintaining faithful responses.

Enhanced trustworthiness in complex interactive settings.

Effective alignment of LLM responses with faithful statements.

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in complex reasoning tasks. However, they can be easily misled by unfaithful arguments during conversations, even when their original statements are correct. To this end, we investigate the problem of maintaining faithful integrity in LLMs. This involves ensuring that LLMs adhere to their faithful statements in the face of opposing arguments and are able to correct their incorrect statements when presented with faithful arguments. In this work, we propose a novel framework, named Alignment for Faithful Integrity with Confidence Estimation (AFICE), which aims to align the LLM responses with faithful integrity. Specifically, AFICE first designs a Bilateral Confidence Estimation (BCE) approach for estimating the uncertainty of each response generated by the LLM given a specific context, which simultaneously estimate the model's confidence to the question based on the internal states during decoding as well as to the answer based on cumulative probability ratios. With the BCE, we construct a conversational preference dataset composed of context, original statement, and argument, which is adopted for aligning the LLM for faithful integrity using Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Extensive experimental results on a wide range of benchmarks demonstrate significant improvements in the LLM's ability to maintain faithful responses when encountering opposing arguments, ensuring both the practical utility and trustworthiness of LLMs in complex interactive settings. Code and data will be released via https://github.com/zhaoy777/AFICE.git