Bayesian Surrogate Training on Multiple Data Sources: A Hybrid Modeling Strategy

TL;DR

This paper introduces two probabilistic hybrid modeling strategies to enhance surrogate models by integrating simulation and real-world data, improving accuracy and diagnosing model issues.

Contribution

The paper proposes two novel methods for combining simulation and measurement data in surrogate training, including a new weighting strategy independent of surrogate type.

Findings

Hybrid approaches improve predictive accuracy and coverage.

The methods help diagnose simulation model problems.

Synthetic and real-world case studies validate the approaches.

Abstract

Surrogate models are often used as computationally efficient approximations to complex simulation models, enabling tasks such as solving inverse problems, sensitivity analysis, and probabilistic forward predictions, which would otherwise be computationally infeasible. During training, surrogate parameters are fitted such that the surrogate reproduces the simulation model's outputs as closely as possible. However, the simulation model itself is merely a simplification of the real-world system, often missing relevant processes or suffering from misspecifications e.g., in inputs or boundary conditions. Hints about these might be captured in real-world measurement data, and yet, we typically ignore those hints during surrogate building. In this paper, we propose two novel probabilistic approaches to integrate simulation data and real-world measurement data during surrogate training. The first method trains separate surrogate models for each data source and combines their predictive distributions, while the second incorporates both data sources by training a single surrogate. Both hybrid modeling approaches employ a novel weighting strategy for combining heterogeneous data sources during surrogate training, which operates independently of the chosen surrogate family. We show the conceptual differences and benefits of the two approaches through both synthetic and real-world case studies. The results demonstrate the potential of these methods to improve predictive accuracy, predictive coverage, and to diagnose problems in the underlying simulation model. These insights can improve system understanding and future model development.