The Status of Neutrino Cosmology: Standard $\Lambda$CDM, Extensions, and Tensions

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the constraints on neutrino properties within the standard $\\Lambda$CDM model and its extensions using diverse cosmological datasets, revealing limits on neutrino masses, preferences for neutrino mass hierarchies, and implications for the Hubble tension.

Contribution

It provides updated cosmological constraints on neutrino masses, hierarchy preferences, and the role of extra relativistic species, integrating multiple datasets and analyses.

Findings

Upper limits on neutrino mass sum: 76.9-108 meV at 95% CL.

Preference for normal neutrino mass ordering at 1.47σ.

Evidence for a partially thermalized sterile neutrino at 3.3σ when including $H_0$ measurements.

Abstract

We examine the performance of the six-parameter $\Lambda$CDM model and its extensions in light of recent cosmological observations, with particular focus on neutrino properties inferred from cosmology. Using a broad suite of nine combinations of datasets, with three separate analyses of the Planck Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data, and three separate supernovae (SNe) survey data, plus the recent DESI baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) scale results, we derive constraints on the sum of neutrino masses ($\Sigma m_\nu$). Our results show upper limits in the range of $\Sigma m_\nu < 76.9\,\mathrm{meV}$ to $\Sigma m_\nu < 108\,\mathrm{meV}$ (95\% CL). The variation in the limits on $\Sigma m_\nu$ arises from the separate analyses of the Planck CMB data and the separate supernovae datasets, as they relate to the inferred matter density and its relation to the sensitivity of the BAO scale and CMB lensing to $\Sigma m_\nu$. In the context of hierarchical mass models in $\Lambda$CDM, we find a $1.47\sigma$ preference for normal ordering (NO) over inverted ordering (IO), with similar values of preference across all datasets. Despite the strong constraints, an inclination towards massless neutrinos over NO remains weak at $1.36\sigma$. We find that a ``negative'' neutrino mass, inferred from the shape of the likelihood in the physical regime, $\Sigma m_\nu > 0$, is only present at less than $2\sigma$. We confirm that models allowing extra relativistic degrees of freedom, with $N_{\rm eff} \approx 3.5$, alleviate the Hubble tension. Significantly, we find a $3.3\sigma$ preference for a 0.1 eV partially thermalized sterile neutrino when the SH0ES $H_0$ measurement is included, a scale of interest in short-baseline oscillation experiment results. [abridged]