Super-Polynomial Growth of the Generalized Persistence Diagram

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that the complexity of computing the Generalized Persistence Diagram (GPD) for multi-parameter persistence can grow faster than polynomial, indicating significant computational challenges in this area.

Contribution

The authors prove that the GPD's support can grow super-polynomially with the size of the filtration, highlighting the inherent difficulty in computing GPDs for multi-parameter persistence.

Findings

GPD support can grow faster than any polynomial in the number of simplices.

Common filtration methods can produce 'wild' filtrations with super-polynomial GPD size.

Computing GPDs is inherently complex due to super-polynomial growth.

Abstract

The Generalized Persistence Diagram (GPD) for multi-parameter persistence naturally extends the classical notion of persistence diagram for one-parameter persistence. However, unlike its classical counterpart, computing the GPD remains a significant challenge. The main hurdle is that, while the GPD is defined as the M\"obius inversion of the Generalized Rank Invariant (GRI), computing the GRI is intractable due to the formidable size of its domain, i.e., the set of all connected and convex subsets in a finite grid in $\mathbb{R}^d$ with $d \geq 2$. This computational intractability suggests seeking alternative approaches to computing the GPD. In order to study the complexity associated to computing the GPD, it is useful to consider its classical one-parameter counterpart, where for a filtration of a simplicial complex with $n$ simplices, its persistence diagram contains at most $n$ points. This observation leads to the question: 'Given a $d$-parameter simplicial filtration, could the cardinality of its GPD (specifically, the support of the GPD) also be bounded by a polynomial in the number of simplices in the filtration?' This is the case for $d=1$, where we compute the persistence diagram directly at the simplicial filtration level. If this were also the case for $d\geq2$, it might be possible to compute the GPD directly and much more efficiently without relying on the GRI. We show that the answer to the question above is negative, demonstrating the inherent difficulty of computing the GPD. More specifically, we construct a sequence of $d$-parameter simplicial filtrations where the cardinalities of their GPDs are not bounded by any polynomial in the the number of simplices. Furthermore, we show that several commonly used methods for constructing multi-parameter filtrations can give rise to such "wild" filtrations.