Cutting Soft Matter: Scaling relations controlled by toughness, friction, and wear

TL;DR

This paper investigates the mechanics of wire cutting in soft solids, revealing how toughness, friction, and wear influence the force-radius relationship, and demonstrating methods to measure toughness and fracture energy from cutting experiments.

Contribution

It introduces a scaling relation linking cutting force, wire radius, toughness, and wear strength, and shows how to extract material toughness and fracture energy from cutting data.

Findings

Force is independent of radius below a transition length.

Toughness correlates with the force intercept, estimating cleavage toughness.

Force slope relates to the work of fracture, indicating dissipative processes.

Abstract

Cutting mechanics of soft solids is gaining rapid attention thanks to its promising benefits in material characterization and other applications. However, a full understanding of the physical phenomena is still missing, and several questions remain outstanding. E.g.: How can we directly and reliably measure toughness from cutting experiments? What is the role of blade sharpness? In this paper, we explore the simple problem of wire cutting, where blade sharpness is only defined by the wire radius. Through finite element analysis, we obtain a simple scaling relation between the wire radius and the steady-state cutting force per unit sample thickness. The cutting force is independent of the wire radius if the latter is below a transition length, while larger radii produce a linear force-radius correlation. The minimum cutting force, for small radii, is given by cleavage toughness, i.e., the surface energy required to break covalent bonds in the crack plane. The force-radius slope is instead given by the wear shear strength in the material. Via cutting experiments on polyacrylamide gels, we find that the magnitude of shear strength is close to the work of fracture of the material, i.e., the critical strain energy density required to break a pristine sample in uniaxial tension. The work of fracture characterizes the toughening contribution from the fracture process zone (FPZ), which adds to cleavage toughness. Our study provides two important messages, that answer the above questions: Toughness can be estimated from wire-cutting experiments from the intercept of the force-radius linear correlation, as previously explored. However, as we discovered, this only estimates cleavage toughness. Additionally, the force-radius slope is correlated with the work of fracture, giving an estimation of the dissipative contributions from the FPZ.