WDD: Weighted Delta Debugging

TL;DR

Weighted Delta Debugging (WDD) enhances traditional delta debugging algorithms by incorporating element weights based on size, significantly improving the efficiency and effectiveness of bug-triggering test input minimization.

Contribution

This paper introduces WDD, a novel approach that assigns weights to input fragments, enabling existing delta debugging algorithms to better handle size variations among elements.

Findings

Wddmin and WProbDD outperform traditional algorithms in benchmarks.

WDD improves minimization efficiency and effectiveness.

Extensive evaluation confirms WDD's value across multiple applications.

Abstract

Delta Debugging is a widely used family of algorithms (e.g., ddmin and ProbDD) to automatically minimize bug-triggering test inputs, thus to facilitate debugging. It takes a list of elements with each element representing a fragment of the test input, systematically partitions the list at different granularities, identifies and deletes bug-irrelevant partitions. Prior delta debugging algorithms assume there are no differences among the elements in the list, and thus treat them uniformly during partitioning. However, in practice, this assumption usually does not hold, because the size (referred to as weight) of the fragment represented by each element can vary significantly. For example, a single element representing 50% of the test input is much more likely to be bug-relevant than elements representing only 1%. This assumption inevitably impairs the efficiency or even effectiveness of these delta debugging algorithms. This paper proposes Weighted Delta Debugging (WDD), a novel concept to help prior delta debugging algorithms overcome the limitation mentioned above. The key insight of WDD is to assign each element in the list a weight according to its size, and distinguish different elements based on their weights during partitioning. We designed two new minimization algorithms, Wddmin and WProbDD, by applying WDD to ddmin and ProbDD respectively. We extensively evaluated Wddmin and WProbDD in two representative applications, HDD and Perses, on 62 benchmarks across two languages. The results strongly demonstrate the value of WDD. We firmly believe that WDD opens up a new dimension to improve test input minimization techniques.