Dataset resulting from the user study on comprehensibility of explainable AI algorithms

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive dataset from a user study on the interpretability of XAI algorithms, including interviews, visualizations, and participant feedback, enabling qualitative analysis of explainability across domains.

Contribution

The paper introduces a detailed, multi-faceted dataset from a user study on XAI comprehensibility, facilitating reproducibility and further research in explainability evaluation.

Findings

Participants from different domains provided diverse insights.

The dataset enables analysis of explanation effectiveness.

Recommendations for improving explanations are included.

Abstract

This paper introduces a dataset that is the result of a user study on the comprehensibility of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) algorithms. The study participants were recruited from 149 candidates to form three groups representing experts in the domain of mycology (DE), students with a data science and visualization background (IT) and students from social sciences and humanities (SSH). The main part of the dataset contains 39 transcripts of interviews during which participants were asked to complete a series of tasks and questions related to the interpretation of explanations of decisions of a machine learning model trained to distinguish between edible and inedible mushrooms. The transcripts were complemented with additional data that includes visualizations of explanations presented to the user, results from thematic analysis, recommendations of improvements of explanations provided by the participants, and the initial survey results that allow to determine the domain knowledge of the participant and data analysis literacy. The transcripts were manually tagged to allow for automatic matching between the text and other data related to particular fragments. In the advent of the area of rapid development of XAI techniques, the need for a multidisciplinary qualitative evaluation of explainability is one of the emerging topics in the community. Our dataset allows not only to reproduce the study we conducted, but also to open a wide range of possibilities for the analysis of the material we gathered.