Do graph neural network states contain graph properties?
Tom Pelletreau-Duris, Ruud van Bakel, Michael Cochez

TL;DR
This paper introduces a model-agnostic explainability pipeline for GNNs that uses diagnostic classifiers to investigate whether GNN states encode structural graph properties, enhancing interpretability.
Contribution
It proposes a novel approach employing diagnostic classifiers to analyze GNN embeddings for graph properties, addressing the interpretability challenge of non-euclidean models.
Findings
GNN states can encode structural graph properties.
The pipeline is effective across various GNN architectures.
It improves understanding of GNN internal representations.
Abstract
Deep neural networks (DNNs) achieve state-of-the-art performance on many tasks, but this often requires increasingly larger model sizes, which in turn leads to more complex internal representations. Explainability techniques (XAI) have made remarkable progress in the interpretability of ML models. However, the non-euclidean nature of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) makes it difficult to reuse already existing XAI methods. While other works have focused on instance-based explanation methods for GNNs, very few have investigated model-based methods and, to our knowledge, none have tried to probe the embedding of the GNNs for structural graph properties. In this paper we present a model agnostic explainability pipeline for Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) employing diagnostic classifiers. We propose to consider graph-theoretic properties as the features of choice for studying the emergence of…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2025
1. Novelty: Proposes a new model-agnostic explainability approach using probing techniques for GNNs, which is less explored than instance-level explanations. 2. Comprehensive Dataset Testing: Validates the method across diverse datasets, showcasing its versatility. 3. Insightful Comparisons: Provides detailed comparative analysis of different GNN architectures (e.g., GCN, GAT, GIN), noting their strengths in capturing specific graph properties.
1. The padding and sorting steps for node embeddings, while intended to address non-uniform node counts, might introduce ordering biases and disrupt permutation invariance. 2. Some limitations in dataset representativity for real-world scenarios, as synthetic datasets like Grid-House may oversimplify the types of structures a GNN may encounter. 3. Fails to fully address the explainability of intermediate GNN layers, focusing more on final representations; probing deeper layers would provide mo
1. The investigation tackles a problem that is both intriguing and significant. To the best of the reviewer's knowledge, this is the inaugural paper to address it. 2. The proposed pipeline is streamlined yet yields effective results. 3. The experimental outcomes provide valuable insights that will benefit future research endeavors.
This paper has several weaknesses. Addressing Weakness 2 & 3 & 4 will make a compelling case for 'accept.' Specifically: 1. The section designated for findings focuses more on articulating the experimental setting rather than the findings themselves. A clearer exposition of the results will fortify this section. (Question 1) 2. The use of GNNs, which are based on message passing and 1-WL, suggests that the inclusion of stronger GNNs could substantiate the experimental framework. (Question 2)
Linear probing is a straightforward yet powerful method, demonstrating strong results across the tested datasets. Its simplicity makes it easy to implement, while still providing valuable insights into the graph properties encoded by the GNNs. Layer-wise analysis holds significant potential for identifying patterns in GNNs, much like the successes achieved in CNNs. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of how GNNs progressively capture and abstract graph properties across different la
"We addressed this by sorting the embeddings in descending order and padding with zeros at the end". However, this solution for handling node features before the global pooling stage seems somewhat arbitrary. An immediate alternative approach could be to consider different pooling strategies and even their concatenation. Furthermore, Probing Graph Representations (Akhondzadeh et al., 2023) conducted a similar probing study, arriving at nearly identical conclusions. As a result, the amount of n
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsAdvanced Graph Neural Networks · Graph Theory and Algorithms · Neural Networks and Applications
