Globular clusters as cosmic clocks: new cosmological hints from their integrated light

TL;DR

This study assesses the reliability of using integrated light measurements of globular clusters to determine their ages, metallicities, and masses, aiming to establish GCs as cosmic clocks for high-redshift cosmology.

Contribution

It introduces a robust method combining Lick indices and full-spectral-fitting to accurately measure GC properties and demonstrates their potential for constraining cosmological parameters.

Findings

Ages are best recovered without cosmological priors, with a 20% increase aligning with literature.

Derived metallicities and masses agree with reference values, with minimal discrepancies.

Identified a tail of old GCs with ages around 13.4 Gyr, useful for cosmological constraints.

Abstract

We explore the reliability and robustness in measuring the age, metallicity and mass of a sample of old Milky Way globular clusters (GCs) from their integrated light, setting the stage for using GCs as cosmic clocks at high redshift. We analyse 77 GCs from the WAGGS project, first by measuring Lick indices and spectroscopic breaks with PyLick, then performing full-spectral-fitting (FSF) with BAGPIPES. The analysis of Lick indices offers an estimate of the GCs' age and [Z/H], generally aligning with literature values, but highlights a subset of old GCs for which we estimate younger ages. This discrepancy is attributed to the presence of blue horizontal branches (HB), which are not accounted for in the stellar population models. With FSF we measure the GCs' ages, [Z/H], and masses, also testing the cosmological prior's impact on ages. Compared to isochrone fitting estimates, ages are best recovered when the cosmological prior is removed, with a 20% increase in GCs' ages compatible with literature values (within $\pm$1.5 Gyr). The derived [Z/H] and mass agree with the reference values, regardless of HB morphology or fit setting, with average discrepancies across the entire sample of $\Delta$[Z/H]=-0.02$\pm$0.24 dex and $\Delta log(M/M_{\odot})=0.04\pm 0.28$ dex. Ages are best recovered for metal-rich GCs ([Z/H]$\geq$-0.4) showing a red HB (HBR>0), with 70% of the results compatible with literature values. Using a Gaussian Mixture Model, we identify a tail of 24 old GCs with age=13.4$\pm$1.1 Gyr. Being a natural lower limit to the age of the Universe, we use this value to constrain $H_0$, obtaining $H_0 = 70.5^{+7.7}_{-6.3}$ km/s/Mpc (stat+syst) when a flat $\Lambda$CDM with $\Omega_m =0.30 \pm 0.02$ is assumed. Validating the study of GCs based on integrated light lays the foundation to extend this type of study to high-z, where lensed GCs have begun to appear, thanks to JWST. (abridged)