Is the finite temperature effective potential, effective for dynamics?

TL;DR

This paper critically examines the use of the finite temperature effective potential for scalar condensate dynamics, revealing significant limitations and proposing a unitary evolution approach for consistent, non-thermal dynamical analysis.

Contribution

It identifies key caveats of the effective potential in dynamical settings and introduces a unitary time evolution framework for accurate, thermodynamically consistent condensate dynamics.

Findings

Finite temperature effective potential has limited validity for dynamical condensates.

Dynamical evolution leads to non-monotonic entropy and non-thermal particle distributions.

A unitary evolution approach provides a consistent framework for studying condensate dynamics.

Abstract

We study the applicability of the finite temperature effective potential in the equation of motion of a homogeneous "misaligned" scalar condensate $\varphi$, and find important caveats that severely restrict its domain of validity: i:) the assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) is in general not warranted, ii:) we show a direct relation between the effective potential and the thermodynamic entropy density $\mathcal{S}= - \partial V_{eff}(T,\varphi)/\partial T$, which entails that for a dynamical $\varphi(t)$ the entropy becomes a non-monotonic function of time, iii:) parametric instabilities in both cases with and without spontaneous symmetry breaking lead to profuse particle production with non-thermal distribution functions, iv:) in the case of spontaneous symmetry breaking spinodal instabilities yield a complex effective potential, internal energy and entropy, an untenable situation in thermodynamics. All these caveats associated with dynamical aspects, cannot be overcome by finite temperature equilibrium resummation schemes. We argue that the dynamics of the condensate leads to decoupling and freeze-out from (LTE), and propose a closed quantum system approach based on unitary time evolution. It yields the correct equations of motion without the caveats of the effective potential, and provides a fully renormalized and thermodynamically consistent framework to study the dynamics of the "misaligned" condensate, with real and conserved energy and entropy amenable to numerical study. The evolution of the condensate leads to profuse stimulated particle production with non-thermal distribution functions. Possible emergent asymptotic non-thermal states and eventual re-thermalization are conjectured.