An Evaluation of Different Numerical Methods to Calculate the Pitch-angle Diffusion Coefficient from Full-orbit Simulations: disentangling a rope of sand

TL;DR

This paper compares nine methods for calculating the pitch-angle diffusion coefficient from full-orbit simulations, identifying their strengths, limitations, and best practices for future research in turbulent magnetic fields.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparative analysis of existing methods, highlighting their applicability and reliability in different turbulence regimes.

Findings

Certain methods are more reliable in weak turbulence conditions.

Some techniques are ill-suited for numerical investigations.

Recommendations for best practices in future studies.

Abstract

The pitch-angle diffusion coefficient quantifies the effect of pitch-angle scattering on charged particles propagating through turbulent magnetic fields and is a key ingredient in understanding the diffusion of these particles along the background magnetic field. Despite its significance, only a limited number of studies have calculated the pitch-angle diffusion coefficient from test particle simulations in synthetic magnetic turbulence, employing various, often quite different, techniques for this purpose. In this study, we undertake a comparative analysis of nine different methods for calculating the pitch-angle diffusion coefficient from full-orbit simulations. Our objective is to find the strengths and limitations of each method and to determine the most reliable approach. Although all nine methods should theoretically yield comparable results, certain methods may be ill-suited for numerical investigations, while others may not be applicable under conditions of strong turbulence. Through this investigation, we aim to provide recommendations for best practices when employing these methods in future numerical studies of pitch-angle scattering.