Quantifying Baryonic Feedback on Warm-Hot Circumgalactic Medium in CAMELS Simulations

TL;DR

This study compares how different subgrid models of stellar and AGN feedback in CAMELS simulations influence baryon behavior, revealing complex interactions and their effects on halo properties across masses and redshifts.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of feedback model impacts on baryons in CAMELS simulations, highlighting the interdependence of stellar and AGN feedback mechanisms.

Findings

IllustrisTNG shows higher cumulative feedback energy than SIMBA.

SIMBA exhibits a greater spread of baryons within halos.

Feedback parameters influence black hole growth and CGM gas fractions.

Abstract

The baryonic physics shaping galaxy formation and evolution are complex, spanning a vast range of scales and making them challenging to model. Cosmological simulations rely on subgrid models that produce significantly different predictions. Understanding how models of stellar and active galactic nuclei (AGN) feedback affect baryon behavior across different halo masses and redshifts is essential. Using the SIMBA and IllustrisTNG suites from the Cosmology and Astrophysics with MachinE Learning Simulations (CAMELS) project, we explore the effect of parameters governing the subgrid implementation of stellar and AGN feedback. We find that while IllustrisTNG shows higher cumulative feedback energy across all halos, SIMBA demonstrates a greater spread of baryons, quantified by the closure radius and circumgalactic medium (CGM) gas fraction. This suggests that feedback in SIMBA couples more effectively to baryons and drives them more efficiently within the host halo. There is evidence that different feedback modes are highly interrelated in these subgrid models. Parameters controlling stellar feedback efficiency significantly impact AGN feedback, as seen in the suppression of black hole mass growth and delayed activation of AGN feedback to higher mass halos with increasing stellar feedback efficiency in both simulations. Additionally, AGN feedback efficiency parameters affect the CGM gas fraction at low halo masses in SIMBA, hinting at complex, non-linear interactions between AGN and SNe feedback modes. Overall, we demonstrate that stellar and AGN feedback are intimately interwoven, especially at low redshift, due to subgrid implementation, resulting in halo property effects that might initially seem counterintuitive.