Suppressed paramagnetism in amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ oxides and its link to superconducting qubit performance

TL;DR

This study uses computational methods to compare amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ and Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ oxides, revealing that Ta-based oxides have fewer magnetic moments and TLS sources, which may explain their superior performance in superconducting qubits.

Contribution

It provides a microscopic understanding of the differences between Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ and Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ amorphous oxides, linking material chemistry to qubit coherence.

Findings

Oxygen deficiency is less likely in amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ than in Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$.

Metal Ta-Ta bonds are enhanced at higher oxygen deficiency levels.

Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ suppresses magnetic moments and TLS formation, unlike Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$.

Abstract

Reduced transmon qubit $T_1$ coherence times have been linked to the amorphous oxide layers formed by thin film capacitors during processing. Because Ta or Ta capped Nb capacitors exhibit overall superior qubit performance to those fabricated with Nb capacitors, it has been hypothesized that the amorphous, non-stoichiometric Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ oxide is less lossy than its Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ counterpart. The origins of what makes amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ less susceptible to accepted decoherence channels is unknown. Here we establish the microscopic features of amorphous Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ and Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ using a combination of \textit{ab initio} molecular dynamics and density functional theory calculations. Our simulations establish that oxygen deficiency is less likely to occur in amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ than in Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ for $0\le x \le 0.25$ and that at a given level of oxygen deficiency the formation of metal Ta-Ta bonds is enhanced. These bonds, which are accommodated by structural flaws in the amorphous network, capture electrons better than in amorphous Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$. These thermochemical differences quench or highly suppress magnetic moments in amorphous Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$ and eliminate a potential source of quasiparticles and magnetic flux noise. Our calculations also show that hyperfine couplings between Nb nuclei and local magnetic moments in Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ could form "two-level systems" (TLS) or "two-level fluctuators" (TLF) with energy splittings of 100-1000 MHz or higher. This reveals a new TLS mechanism in amorphous Nb$_2$O$_{5-x}$ oxide layers that is unlikely in Ta$_2$O$_{5-x}$. Our work provides fundamental understanding of the materials chemistry and limitations imposed by native oxides of superconducting qubits, which can be used to guide materials selection and processing.