Differential reflectivity columns and hail -- linking C-band radar-based estimated column characteristics to crowdsourced hail observations in Switzerland

TL;DR

This study explores how differential reflectivity columns detected by C-band radar in Switzerland relate to hail reports, showing potential for early hail warning by analyzing ZDRC characteristics in complex alpine terrain.

Contribution

It adapts and applies an existing ZDRC detection algorithm to Swiss radar data, linking ZDRC features to ground hail reports and assessing their potential for hail prediction.

Findings

ZDRC are common in hail-producing storms

Higher ZDRC frequencies correlate with severe hail

Peak ZDRC values occur 5-10 minutes before hail reports

Abstract

Differential reflectivity columns (ZDRC) have been shown to provide information about a storm's updraft intensity and size. The updraft's characteristics, in turn, influence a severe storm's propensity to produce hail and the size of said hail. Consequently, there is the potential to use ZDRC for the detection and sizing of hail. In this observational study, we investigate the characteristics of ZDRC (volume, height, area, maximum ZDR within) automatically detected on an operational C-band radar network in Switzerland and relate them to hail on the ground using 173'000 crowdsourced hail reports collected over a period of 3.5 years. We implement an adapted version of an established ZDRC detection algorithm on a 3D composite of ZDR data derived from five Swiss weather radars. The composite, in combination with the dense network of radars located on differing altitudes up to 3000 m.a.s.l, helps to counteract the effects of the complex topography of the study region. The alpine region presents visibility and data quality challenges, which are especially crucial for measuring ZDRC. Our analysis finds ZDRC present in most hail-producing storms, with higher frequencies in storms producing severe hail. Further, when looking at lifetime maximum values, we find significant differences in various ZDRC characteristics between hail-producing and non-hail-producing storms. We also attempt to determine thresholds to differentiate between storm types. The temporal evolution of the ZDRC proves challenging to investigate due to their intermittent nature. Nevertheless, the peak values of the ZDRC characteristics are most often measured 5-10 minutes before the first hail reports on the ground, highlighting the potential for ZDRC to be used in warning applications.