Proton arc therapy plan optimization with energy layer pre-selection driven by organ at risk sparing and delivery time

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel energy layer pre-selection method for proton arc therapy that reduces delivery time by 20-40% while maintaining high-quality target coverage and organ sparing, using a metaheuristic-based bi-objective optimization approach.

Contribution

Introduces a flexible, fast energy layer pre-selection algorithm for proton arc therapy that balances delivery time and dosimetric quality using metaheuristics.

Findings

Pre-selection algorithm generates Pareto-optimal solutions in ~5 minutes.

Achieves 20-40% reduction in delivery time compared to existing methods.

Maintains high target coverage and organ-at-risk sparing.

Abstract

Objective. As proton arc therapy (PAT) approaches clinical implementation, optimizing treatment plans for this innovative delivery modality remains challenging, especially in addressing arc delivery time. Existing algorithms for minimizing delivery time are either optimal but computationally demanding or fast but at the expense of sacrificing many degrees of freedom. In this study, we introduce a flexible method for pre-selecting energy layers (EL) in PAT treatment planning before the actual robust spot weight optimization. Our EL pre-selection method employs metaheuristics to minimize a bi-objective function, considering a dynamic delivery time proxy and tumor geometrical coverage penalized as a function of selected organs-at-risk crossing. It is capable of parallelizing multiple instances of the problem. We evaluate the method using three different treatment sites, providing a comprehensive dosimetric analysis benchmarked against dynamic proton arc plans generated with early energy layer selection and spot assignment (ELSA) and IMPT plans in RayStation TPS. The algorithm efficiently generates Pareto-optimal EL pre-selections in approximately 5 minutes. Subsequent PAT treatment plans derived from these selections and optimized within the TPS, demonstrate high-quality target coverage, achieving a high conformity index, and effective sparing of organs at risk. These plans meet clinical goals while achieving a 20 to 40% reduction in delivery time compared to ELSA plans. The proposed algorithm offers speed and efficiency, producing high-quality PAT plans by placing proton arc sectors to efficiently reduce delivery time while maintaining good target coverage and healthy tissues sparing.