No Maunder Minimum phase in HD 4915

TL;DR

This study investigates the long-term magnetic activity of star HD 4915 to determine if it experienced a Maunder Minimum-like phase, using extensive spectroscopic data to analyze activity cycles and conclude it did not.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed analysis of HD 4915's activity over nearly two decades, demonstrating it did not enter a Maunder Minimum phase, and identifies a complex multi-cycle activity pattern.

Findings

HD 4915's activity increased after a broad minimum, indicating no Maunder Minimum.

The star exhibits a multi-cycle activity pattern with a 4.8-year cycle.

Extended observations are essential for accurately identifying stellar magnetic minima.

Abstract

The long-term solar magnetic activity and its cyclical behaviour, which is maintained by a dynamo mechanism, are both still challenging for the astrophysics. In particular, an atypical event occurred between 1645 and 1715 when the solar activity was remarkably decreased and the number of sunspots got extremely reduced. However, it is still unclear what happened to the solar cycle. The discovery of longer activity minima in cool stars may shed light on the nature of the complex mechanisms involved in the long-term behaviour of the solar-stellar dynamo. Our aim is to explore if the G5V solar-like star HD 4915, which showed a striking chromospheric activity pattern in a previous study performed with HIRES data, could be considered a bona fide Maunder Minimum (hereafter MM) candidate. We have analyzed over 380 spectra acquired between 2003 and 2022 using HARPS and HIRES spectrographs. We carried out a detailed search of activity signatures in HD 4915 by using the Mount Wilson and the Balmer H$_{\alpha}$ activity indexes. This task was performed by means of the GLS periodogram. The new HARPS data show that the chromospheric activity of HD 4915 is not decreasing. In fact, the rise of the activity after the broad minimum in three years gets to the level of activity before that phase, suggesting that it is not entering into a MM phase. HD 4915 shows a distinctive activity behaviour initially attributed to a possible and incipient MM phase. The additional HARPS data allow us to discard a MM in the star. Our analysis shows that the complex activity pattern of HD 4915 could be ruled by a multiple activity cycle, being a shorter cycle of 4.8-yr modulated by a potential longer one. More activity surveys with extensive records and suitable cadence are crucial for accurate identification of stars in Magnetic Grand Minima.