Radial Basis Operator Networks
Jason Kurz, Sean Oughton, Shitao Liu

TL;DR
The paper introduces the radial basis operator network (RBON), a novel operator network capable of learning in both time and frequency domains with complex inputs, achieving extremely low error rates in scientific computing tasks.
Contribution
It presents the first operator network that learns in both time and frequency domains with complex inputs, demonstrating high accuracy and robustness in scientific applications.
Findings
Achieves less than 1e-7 test error in benchmark cases.
Maintains small error on out-of-distribution data.
Effective in scientific computing contexts like climate modeling.
Abstract
Operator networks are designed to approximate nonlinear operators, which provide mappings between infinite-dimensional spaces such as function spaces. These networks are playing an increasingly important role in machine learning, with their most notable contributions in the field of scientific computing. Their significance stems from their ability to handle the type of data often encountered in scientific applications. For instance, in climate modeling or fluid dynamics, input data typically consists of discretized continuous fields (like temperature distributions or velocity fields). We introduce the radial basis operator network (RBON), which represents a significant advancement as the first operator network capable of learning an operator in both the time domain and frequency domain when adjusted to accept complex-valued inputs. Despite the small, single hidden-layer structure, the…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Conference Withdrawn Submission
The paper is well written and the topic is interesting though not mainstream. The experiments are relevant.
The methodological description of the method is too short and not detailed enough, especially for unfamiliar readers. Some theoretical statements are made but the rest of the methodology would not allow re-implmenting the method. Figs 1 and 2 do not carry any information whatsoever; most equations about the network are implicitly embedded in the theorem. Part of the problem is that the paper describes a variant of NO/ON and the authors focus on the increment, probably for the sake of space, at t
Paper proposes a new operator network based on radial basis functions. Paper is clearly written. The quantitative results of RBON, NRBON, and F-RBON outperform LNO on the wave, burgers, and Euler-bernoulli beam equations.
small set of experiments. CO2 to temperature experiment lacks baseline. other factors than CO2 affect temperature, and overall there's a lot of fluctuation in temperature, so it is hard to tell how good predictions are from the RBONs. another dataset with experiments may be helpful.
Replacing the DNN in DeepONet with the radial basis neural network sounds an interesting idea, leading to improved numerical results.
1. The presentation is unclear, making it challenging for readers unfamiliar with DeepONet to follow. For example, it lacks a clear outline (or pseudo) of the training algorithm for the proposed network. What are the training parameters? How should M and N be selected? 2. Figure 1: what does `x' represent? Does the linear transformation L include tunable parameters? 3. In Section 2.3, the authors mentioned computation in the frequency domain, but the algorithm is not detailed. 4. The com
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsNeural Networks and Applications · Topology Optimization in Engineering
