The effect of gravity on bubble-particle collisions in turbulence

TL;DR

This study investigates how gravity influences bubble-particle collisions in turbulence, revealing complex effects like spatial segregation and collision rate variations, and extends existing models for better quantitative predictions.

Contribution

It provides the first direct numerical simulation analysis of gravity effects on bubble-particle collisions in turbulence and extends a collision model for improved accuracy.

Findings

Turbulence generally increases collision rates compared to pure settling.

Under certain conditions, turbulence reduces collision rates due to spatial segregation.

An extended collision model shows excellent agreement with simulation data for small Stokes numbers.

Abstract

Bubble-particle collisions in turbulence are key to the froth flotation process that is widely employed industrially to separate hydrophobic from hydrophilic materials. In our previous study (Chan et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 959, 2023, A6), we elucidated the collision mechanisms and critically reviewed the collision models in the no-gravity limit. In reality, gravity may play a role since ultimately separation is achieved through buoyancy-induced rising of the bubbles. This effect has been included in several collision models, which have remained without a proper validation thus far due to a scarcity of available data. We therefore conduct direct numerical simulations of bubbles and particles in homogeneous isotropic turbulence with various Stokes, Froude, Reynolds numbers, and particle density ratios using the point-particle approximation. Generally, turbulence enhances the collision rate compared to the pure relative settling case by increasing the collision velocity. Surprisingly, however, for certain parameters the collision rate is lower with turbulence compared to without, independent of the history force. This is due to turbulence-induced bubble-particle spatial segregation, which is most prevalent at weak relative gravity and decreases as gravitational effects become more dominant, and reduced bubble slip velocity in turbulence. The existing bubble-particle collision models only qualitatively capture the trends in our numerical data. To improve on this, we extend the model by Dodin & Elperin (Phys. Fluids, vol. 14, no. 8, 2002, pp.2921-2924) to the bubble-particle case and found excellent quantitative agreement for small Stokes numbers when the history force is negligible and segregation is accounted for.