Residual Energy and Broken Symmetry in Reduced Magnetohydrodynamics

TL;DR

This paper investigates the origin of negative residual energy in magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, showing that initial conditions break the symmetry of reduced MHD equations, leading to net-negative residual energy in certain modes, relevant for solar wind turbulence.

Contribution

It provides an intuitive physical explanation for the preference of negative residual energy in MHD turbulence by analyzing symmetry breaking in reduced MHD equations.

Findings

Negative residual energy arises from symmetry breaking in initial conditions.

Resonant and nonresonant modes contribute to residual energy dynamics.

Initial value problem better models solar wind turbulence.

Abstract

Alfv\'enic interactions which transfer energy from large to small spatial scales lie at the heart of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. An important feature of the turbulence is the generation of negative residual energy -- excess energy in magnetic fluctuations compared to velocity fluctuations. By contrast, an MHD Alfv\'en wave has equal amounts of energy in fluctuations of each type. Alfv\'enic quasimodes that do not satisfy the Alfv\'en wave dispersion relation and exist only in the presence of a nonlinear term can contain either positive or negative residual energy, but until now an intuitive physical explanation for why negative residual energy is preferred has remained elusive. This paper shows that the equations of reduced MHD are symmetric in that they have no intrinsic preference for one sign of the residual energy over the other. An initial state that is not an exact solution to the equations can break this symmetry in a way that leads to net-negative residual energy generation. Such a state leads to a solution with three distinct parts: nonresonant Alfv\'enic quasimodes, normal modes produced to satisfy initial conditions, and resonant normal modes that grow in time. The latter two parts strongly depend on initial conditions; the resulting symmetry breaking leads to net-negative residual energy both in Alfv\'enic quasimodes and $\omega=k_\parallel{V_A}=0$ modes. These modes have net-positive residual energy in the equivalent boundary value problem, suggesting that the initial value setup is a better match for solar wind turbulence.