Positional Encoder Graph Quantile Neural Networks for Geographic Data
William E. R. de Amorim, Scott A. Sisson, T. Rodrigues, David J. Nott, Guilherme S. Rodrigues

TL;DR
This paper introduces PE-GQNN, a novel neural network framework that enhances spatial data modeling by improving predictive accuracy and uncertainty quantification through combining positional encoding, quantile estimation, and calibration techniques.
Contribution
The paper presents PE-GQNN, a new framework that integrates PE-GNNs with quantile neural networks and calibration methods for better density estimation and uncertainty quantification.
Findings
PE-GQNN outperforms existing models in accuracy and calibration on benchmark datasets.
The method extends naturally to non-spatial tasks.
It achieves these improvements with minimal additional computational cost.
Abstract
Positional Encoder Graph Neural Networks (PE-GNNs) are among the most effective models for learning from continuous spatial data. However, their predictive distributions are often poorly calibrated, limiting their utility in applications that require reliable uncertainty quantification. We propose the Positional Encoder Graph Quantile Neural Network (PE-GQNN), a novel framework that combines PE-GNNs with Quantile Neural Networks, partially monotonic neural blocks, and post-hoc recalibration techniques. The PE-GQNN enables flexible and robust conditional density estimation with minimal assumptions about the target distribution, and it extends naturally to tasks beyond spatial data. Empirical results on benchmark datasets show that the PE-GQNN outperforms existing methods in both predictive accuracy and uncertainty quantification, without incurring additional computational cost. We also…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Conference Withdrawn Submission
- PE-GQNN combines quantile prediction and distribution recalibration in a single model (not two-stage models), enhancing both predictive accuracy and calibration efficiency. - By limiting GNN operations to specific features and introducing target values near the output layer, the model effectively prevents data leakage and improves computational efficiency. - The authors use pinball loss for quantile regression, which allows one to provide a regularization effect, improving prediction reliabili
- The proposed method is practically useful, but the way PE-GNN and QNN are combined is somewhat straightforward. - There are several innovations in the architecture, but they are all practical techniques, not theoretically sophisticated. - There is no discussion of computational cost for high-dimensional data. - There is no discussion of the shortcomings of the proposed method.
1. The framework is easy to understand and follow. 2. The final experimental results indicate some effectiveness of the proposed method.
1. The term "fully nonparametric" could be misleading. It would be more accurate to use "distribution-free." 2. The novelty of the proposed method is limited. Quantile regression is already proposed and widely used in distribution-free uncertainty quantification. For example: - "Single-model uncertainties for deep learning." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 32 (2019). - "Image-to-image regression with distribution-free uncertainty quantification and applications in imagin
Proposed some techniques for quantifying uncertainty in spatial regression. Experiments with three datasets.
The technical contribution of this paper is limited since the proposed method is a combination of Positional Encoder Graph Neural Networks and quantile regression. The proposed method introduces some techniques, such as the use of response variables y and quantile parameters tau in neural networks. However, the novelty of these techniques is incremental. The experimental results are not convincing. There have been proposed many quantile regression methods in neural networks; i.e., outputting va
There are several strengths demonstrated in the paper: 1. The paper introduces the Positional Encoder Graph Quantile Neural Network (PE-GQNN), a new approach that integrates PE-GNNs, Quantile Neural Networks, and recalibration techniques in a fully nonparametric framework, requiring minimal assumptions about the predictive distributions. 2. The paper has demonstrated the results on three datasets: California Housing, Air Temperature, and 3Droad with 6 different approaches including the proposed
The weaknesses of this paper are listed as the following: 1. The innovation of this paper seems incremental. Positional Encoder Graph Quantile Neural Network (PE-GQNN) is just a simple combination of PE-GNN with Quantile regression model. First, the paper shall illustrate in detail the challenges in the integration process. Normally a good integration will include some short cuts to reduce the total cost while comparing with the cost of simple addition of several algorithms together directly.
Code & Models
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsData Management and Algorithms · Geographic Information Systems Studies · Advanced Clustering Algorithms Research
