Rare Events and Griffiths Phases in Topological Quantum Error Correction

TL;DR

This paper investigates how rare, correlated error events affect the performance of quantum error correction codes, revealing phase transitions and failure mechanisms in 1D and 2D topological codes.

Contribution

It introduces a detailed analysis of rare event effects on QEC, identifying Griffiths phases in 1D codes and failure modes in 2D codes due to non-uniform error distributions.

Findings

In 1D codes, a Griffiths phase with stretched exponential decay of failure rates.

In 2D toric codes, rare events cause threshold loss and decoding failure.

Rare, extended error regions significantly impact QEC performance.

Abstract

The performance of quantum error correcting (QEC) codes are often studied under the assumption of spatio-temporally uniform error rates. On the other hand, experimental implementations almost always produce heterogeneous error rates, in either space or time, as a result of effects such as imperfect fabrication and/or cosmic rays. It is therefore important to understand if and how their presence can affect the performance of QEC in qualitative ways. In this work, we study effects of non-uniform error rates in the representative examples of the 1D repetition code and the 2D toric code, focusing on when they have extended spatio-temporal correlations; these may arise, for instance, from rare events (such as cosmic rays) that temporarily elevate error rates over the entire code patch. These effects can be described in the corresponding statistical mechanics models for decoding, where long-range correlations in the error rates lead to extended rare regions of weaker coupling. For the 1D repetition code where the rare regions are linear, we find two distinct decodable phases: a conventional ordered phase in which logical failure rates decay exponentially with the code distance, and a rare-region dominated Griffiths phase in which failure rates are parametrically larger and decay as a stretched exponential. In particular, the latter phase is present when the error rates in the rare regions are above the bulk threshold. For the 2D toric code where the rare regions are planar, we find no decodable Griffiths phase: rare events which boost error rates above the bulk threshold lead to an asymptotic loss of threshold and failure to decode. Unpacking the failure mechanism implies that techniques for suppressing extended sequences of repeated rare events (which, without intervention, will be statistically present with high probability) will be crucial for QEC with the toric code.