Effects of fetch length on turbulent boundary layer recovery past a step-change in surface roughness

TL;DR

This study investigates the minimum fetch length required for turbulent boundary layers to recover after a step-change in surface roughness, providing insights into flow development and skin friction prediction.

Contribution

It identifies the minimum equilibrium fetch length for TBL recovery over roughness step-changes and quantifies the associated errors in skin friction estimates.

Findings

Full equilibrium recovery occurs at approximately 20δ₂ fetch length.

Skin friction recovers within 10% of its final value at fetch lengths ≥ 5δ₂.

The results inform better modeling of roughness effects on turbulent boundary layers.

Abstract

Recent studies focusing on the response of turbulent boundary layers (TBL) to a step-change in roughness have provided insight into the scaling and characterisation of TBLs and the development of the internal layer. Although various step-change combinations have been investigated, ranging from smooth-to-rough to rough-to-smooth, the "minimum" required roughness fetch length over which the TBL returns to its homogeneously rough behaviour remains unclear. Moreover, the relationship between a finite- and infinite-fetch roughness function (and the equivalent sandgrain roughness) is also unknown. In this study, we determine the minimum "equilibrium fetch length" for TBL developing over a smooth-to-rough step-change as well as the expected error in local skin friction if the fetch length is under this minimum threshold. An experimental study is carried out where the flow is initially developed over a smooth wall, and then a step-change is introduced using patches of P24 sandpaper. 12 roughness fetch lengths are tested in this study, systematically increasing from $L = 1\delta_2$ up to $L = 39\delta_2$ (where \textit{L} is the roughness fetch length and $\delta_2$ is the TBL thickness of the longest fetch case), measured over a range of Reynolds numbers ($4\cdot10^2 \leq Re_\tau \leq 2\cdot10^5$). Results show that the minimum fetch length needed to achieve full equilibrium recovery is around $20\delta_2$. Furthermore, we observe that $C_f$ recovers to within 10\% of its recovered value for fetch lengths $\geq 5\delta_2$. This information allows us to incorporate the effects of roughness fetch length on the skin friction and roughness function.