Silver electrodes are highly selective for CO in CO$_2$ electroreduction due to interplay between voltage dependent kinetics and thermodynamics

TL;DR

This study explains why silver electrodes are highly selective for CO in CO2 electroreduction, combining theoretical calculations and experiments to reveal the interplay of voltage-dependent kinetics and thermodynamics.

Contribution

It provides an atomic-scale understanding of the high CO selectivity of silver electrocatalysts through combined computational and experimental analysis.

Findings

Silver electrodes achieve over 90% CO faradaic efficiency below -1 V vs. RHE.

Formation of formic acid is suppressed due to low hydrogen coverage and kinetic barriers.

Thermodynamic instability of *COOH until -1 V explains voltage-dependent selectivity.

Abstract

Electrochemical reduction is a promising way to make use of CO$_2$ as feedstock for generating renewable fuel and valuable chemicals. Several metals can be used in the electrocatalyst to generate CO and formic acid but hydrogen formation is an unwanted side reaction that can even be dominant. The lack of selectivity is in general a significant problem, but silver-based electrocatalysts have been shown to be highly selective for CO with over over 90% faradaic efficiency when the applied voltage is below -1 V vs. RHE. Hydrogen formation is then insignificant and little formate is formed even though it is thermodynamically favored. We present calculations of the activation free energy for the various elementary steps as a function of applied voltage at the three low index facets, Ag(111), Ag(100) and Ag(110), as well as experimental measurements on polycrystalline electrodes, to identify the reason for this high selectivity. The formation of formic acid is suppressed because of the low coverage of adsorbed hydrogen and kinetic hindrance to the formation of the HCOO* intermediate, while *COOH, a key intermediate in CO formation, is thermodynamically unstable until the applied voltage reaches -1 V vs. RHE, at which point the kinetics for its formation are more favorable than for hydrogen. The calculated results are consistent with experimental measurements carried out for acidic conditions and provide an atomic scale insight into the high CO selectivity of silver-based electrocatalysts.