The solar beryllium abundance revisited with 3D non-LTE models

TL;DR

This study revises the solar beryllium abundance using advanced 3D non-LTE models, revealing a lower surface abundance than previously thought and indicating additional depletion processes not accounted for in standard models.

Contribution

It presents the first comprehensive 3D non-LTE analysis of solar beryllium, simultaneously addressing multiple systematic errors in abundance determination.

Findings

Derived a solar beryllium abundance of 1.21 dex, lower than previous estimates.

Found evidence for 22% beryllium depletion from the solar surface.

Highlighted discrepancies with standard solar models, suggesting missing physics.

Abstract

The present-day abundance of beryllium in the solar atmosphere provides clues about mixing mechanisms within stellar interiors. However, abundance determinations based on the Be II 313.107 nm line are prone to systematic errors due to imperfect model spectra. These errors arise from missing continuous opacity in the UV, a significant unidentified blend at 313.102 nm, departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), and microturbulence and macroturbulence fudge parameters associated with one-dimensional (1D) hydrostatic model atmospheres. Although these factors have been discussed in the literature, no study has yet accounted for all of them simultaneously. To address this, we present 3D non-LTE calculations for neutral and ionised beryllium in the Sun. We used these models to derive the present-day solar beryllium abundance, calibrating the missing opacity on high resolution solar irradiance data and the unidentified blend on the centre-to-limb variation. We find a surface abundance of 1.21 $\pm$ 0.05 dex, which is significantly lower than the value of 1.38 dex that has been commonly adopted since 2004. Taking the initial abundance via CI chondrites, our result implies that beryllium has been depleted from the surface by an extra 0.11 $\pm$ 0.06 dex, or 22 $\pm$ 11%, on top of any effects of atomic diffusion. This is in tension with standard solar models, which predict negligible depletion, as well as with contemporary solar models that have extra mixing calibrated on the abundances of helium and lithium, which predict excessive depletion. These discrepancies highlight the need for further improvements to the physics in solar and stellar models.