On the Reliability of Radio Frequency Fingerprinting

TL;DR

This paper investigates the reliability of radio frequency fingerprinting (RFF) for device identification, revealing its mutational and ephemeral nature due to FPGA reloading, and proposing a probabilistic, multi-sample approach for improved accuracy.

Contribution

It provides an in-depth analysis of RFF reliability, introduces a graph-based mutation abstraction, and demonstrates the need for multiple samples to ensure fingerprint stability.

Findings

Fingerprint mutations occur with FPGA reloading.

RF fingerprints are probabilistic and time-independent.

Multiple samples improve fingerprint reliability.

Abstract

Radio Frequency Fingerprinting (RFF) offers a unique method for identifying devices at the physical (PHY) layer based on their RF emissions due to intrinsic hardware differences. Nevertheless, RFF techniques depend on the ability to extract information from the PHY layer of the radio spectrum by resorting to Software Defined Radios (SDR). Previous works have highlighted the so-called ``Day-After-Tomorrow'' effect, i.e., an intrinsic issue of SDRs leading to a fingerprint mutation following a radio power cycle. In this work, we extend such a study by demonstrating that fingerprint mutations appear every time a new FPGA image is reloaded, i.e., when the SDR initiates a new communication. In this context, we provide an in-depth analysis of the reliability of RFF over multiple FPGA image reloading operations, highlighting its ephemeral and mutational nature. We introduce a methodology for abstracting fingerprint mutations into a graph and provide a theoretical framework for assessing fingerprint reliability. Our results show that the common assumption of considering the RF fingerprint as unique and always persistent is incorrect. By combining real-world measurements, high-performance SDRs, and state-of-the-art deep learning techniques, we experimentally demonstrate that radio devices feature multiple fingerprints that can be clustered according to shared features. Moreover, we show that the RF fingerprint is a time-independent probabilistic phenomenon, which requires the collection of multiple samples to achieve the necessary reliability.