When do molecular polaritons behave like optical filters?

TL;DR

This review explains how molecular polaritons can act as optical filters in the linear regime, showing that many effects attributed to polaritons can be replicated with shaped laser pulses without a cavity.

Contribution

It provides a unified framework distinguishing classical linear optical effects from quantum phenomena in molecular polariton systems, clarifying when cavities are essential.

Findings

Absorption in cavities can be modeled as the overlap of polariton transmission and molecular absorption.

Many polaritonic effects can be replicated with shaped laser pulses without the cavity.

The review clarifies the boundary between classical and quantum effects in polariton phenomena.

Abstract

This review outlines several linear optical effects featured by molecular polaritons arising in the collective strong light-matter coupling regime. Under weak laser irradiation and when the single-molecule light-matter coupling can be neglected (often in the limit when the number of molecules per photon mode is large), we show that the excited-state molecular dynamics under collective strong coupling can be exactly replicated without the cavity using a shaped (or ``filtered'') laser, whose field amplitude is enhanced by the cavity quality factor, shining on the bare molecules. As a consequence, the absorption within a cavity can be understood as the overlap between the polariton transmission and the bare molecular absorption, suggesting that polaritons act in part as optical filters. This framework demystifies and provides a straightforward explanation for a large class of experiments and theoretical models in molecular polaritonics, highlighting that the same effects can be achieved without the cavity with shaped laser pulses. With a few modifications, this simple conceptual picture can also be adapted to understand the incoherent nonlinear response of polaritonic systems. This review establishes a clear distinction between polaritonic phenomena that can be fully explained through classical linear optics and those that require a quantum electrodynamics approach. It also highlights the need to differentiate between effects that necessitate polaritons (i.e., hybrid light-matter states) and those that can occur in the weak coupling regime. We further discuss that certain quantum optical effects like fluorescence can be partially described as optical filtering, whereas some others like cavity-induced Raman scattering go beyond this. Further exploration in these areas is needed to uncover novel polaritonic phenomena beyond optical filtering.