Experimental minimum of condensed-phase optical refrigeration

TL;DR

This paper proposes standardized experimental minimum criteria for reporting optical refrigeration results to improve reliability, reproducibility, and comparison across different materials and studies in the field.

Contribution

It introduces an Experimental Minimum (EM) framework outlining key criteria for validating optical refrigeration claims.

Findings

Established four core criteria for reliable optical refrigeration reporting

Provided a systematic guide to evaluate existing and future research claims

Aimed to enhance reproducibility and comparability in the field

Abstract

Since the first demonstration of optical refrigeration in a rare-earth-doped glass nearly 30 years ago, the nascent field of laser cooling solids has progressed significantly. It is now possible to demonstrate payload cooling to ~91 K using laser-excited ytterbium-doped fluoride crystals. Realizing lower temperatures, however, requires achieving ultrahigh purities in existing rare earth-doped crystals or establishing new cooling media. For the latter, semiconductors are an obvious choice given higher cooling power densities and predicted cooling floors as low as 10 K. This has stimulated a race to demonstrate the optical refrigeration of a semiconductor. It is therefore timely to systematize the necessary and sufficient experimental minimum criteria for reporting optical refrigeration results to elevate the reliability and reproducibility of current and future optical refrigeration claims. We distill an optical refrigeration Experimental Minimum (EM) that we propose will standardize the reporting of new cooling results. EM tenets fall into the following categories: demonstrations of explicit heating vs cooling, optical cooling metrics, thermodynamic consistency, and reliable temperature measurements. All optical refrigeration claims should demonstrate the above four criteria to ensure their reliability and verifiability. We further propose that the EM serve as a guide for reviewing literature claims in the field.