Weighted Brier Score -- an Overall Summary Measure for Risk Prediction Models with Clinical Utility Consideration

TL;DR

This paper introduces a weighted Brier score tailored to evaluate the clinical utility of risk prediction models, decomposing it into discrimination and calibration, and demonstrating its application with prostate cancer data.

Contribution

It proposes a novel weighted Brier score aligned with clinical utility, linking it to the $H$ measure and providing a comprehensive evaluation framework for risk models.

Findings

Weighted Brier score effectively assesses clinical utility.

Decomposition reveals contributions of discrimination and calibration.

Application to prostate cancer data demonstrates practical utility.

Abstract

As advancements in novel biomarker-based algorithms and models accelerate disease risk prediction and stratification in medicine, it is crucial to evaluate these models within the context of their intended clinical application. Prediction models output the absolute risk of disease; subsequently, patient counseling and shared decision-making are based on the estimated individual risk and cost-benefit assessment. The overall impact of the application is often referred to as clinical utility, which received significant attention in terms of model assessment lately. The classic Brier score is a popular measure of prediction accuracy; however, it is insufficient for effectively assessing clinical utility. To address this limitation, we propose a class of weighted Brier scores that aligns with the decision-theoretic framework of clinical utility. Additionally, we decompose the weighted Brier score into discrimination and calibration components, examining how weighting influences the overall score and its individual components. Through this decomposition, we link the weighted Brier score to the $H$ measure, which has been proposed as a coherent alternative to the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve. This theoretical link to the $H$ measure further supports our weighting method and underscores the essential elements of discrimination and calibration in risk prediction evaluation. The practical use of the weighted Brier score as an overall summary is demonstrated using data from the Prostate Cancer Active Surveillance Study (PASS).