Reduced-Rank Estimation for Ill-Conditioned Stochastic Linear Model with High Signal-to-Noise Ratio

TL;DR

This paper investigates the effectiveness of reduced-rank estimators in high SNR scenarios with ill-conditioned models, providing explicit conditions for their superiority over traditional MMSE estimators.

Contribution

It derives explicit conditions under which reduced-rank estimators outperform MMSE in high SNR, especially for ill-conditioned matrices, extending previous numerical findings.

Findings

Reduced-rank estimators outperform MMSE under certain perturbations.

Explicit sufficient conditions for estimator superiority are provided.

Numerical simulations confirm theoretical results.

Abstract

Reduced-rank approach has been used for decades in robust linear estimation of both deterministic and random vector of parameters in linear model y=Hx+\sqrt{epsilon}n. In practical settings, estimation is frequently performed under incomplete or inexact model knowledge, which in the stochastic case significantly increases mean-square-error (MSE) of an estimate obtained by the linear minimum mean-square-error (MMSE) estimator, which is MSE-optimal among linear estimators in the theoretical case of perfect model knowledge. However, the improved performance of reduced-rank estimators over MMSE estimator in estimation under incomplete or inexact model knowledge has been established to date only by means of numerical simulations and arguments indicating that the reduced-rank approach may provide improved performance over MMSE estimator in certain settings. In this paper we focus on the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) case, which has not been previously considered as a natural area of application of reduced-rank estimators. We first show explicit sufficient conditions under which familiar reduced-rank MMSE and truncated SVD estimators achieve lower MSE than MMSE estimator if singular values of array response matrix H are perturbed. We then extend these results to the case of a generic perturbation of array response matrix H, and demonstrate why MMSE estimator frequently attains higher MSE than reduced-rank MMSE and truncated SVD estimators if H is ill-conditioned. The main results of this paper are verified in numerical simulations.