Nonlinear dynamics of vortex pairing in transitional jets

TL;DR

This paper explores the nonlinear vortex pairing mechanisms in transitional jets, revealing how fundamental and subharmonic frequencies interact and dominate flow dynamics despite differences in spectral energy.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of vortex pairing and clarifies the fundamental frequency's role, distinguishing it from the most energetic spectral peak.

Findings

Fundamental frequency is the fourth largest spectral peak but is dynamically dominant.

Vortex pairing involves energy transfer from the mean flow and reverse cascade from fundamental to subharmonics.

Resonance between fundamental and subharmonic supports energy transfer during transition.

Abstract

This study investigates the onset of linear instabilities and their later nonlinear interactions in the shear layer of an initially-laminar jet using a combination of stability analysis and data from high-fidelity flow simulations. We provide a complete picture of the vortex-pairing process. Hydrodynamic instabilities initiate the transition to turbulence, causing the shear layer to spread rapidly. In this process, the shear layer rolls up to form vortices, accompanied by the exponential growth of the fundamental frequency. As the fundamental frequency grows, it gains energy from the mean flow. Subsequently, as it saturates and begins to decay, the fundamental vortices start to pair. During this vortex pairing process, the subharmonic vortex acquires energy both linearly from the mean flow and nonlinearly through a reverse cascade from the fundamental. The process concludes when the subharmonic vortex eventually saturates. Similarly, two subharmonic vortices merge to form a second subharmonic vortex. Our results confirm Kelly's (1967) hypothesis of a resonance mechanism between the fundamental and subharmonic, which supplies energy to the subharmonic. In this multi-tonal, convective-dominated flow, we clarify the ambiguity surrounding the fundamental frequency by demonstrating that the spatially most amplified frequency should be considered fundamental, rather than the structure associated with the spectral energy peak. For the initially-laminar jet considered here, the fundamental frequency corresponds to the fourth largest spectral peak, highlighting the important distinction between the energetically and dynamical significance of a tone. Despite its low energy, the fundamental frequency is dynamically dominant as it determines all other spectral peaks and supplies energy to the subharmonics through a reverse energy cascade.