Asymmetric Hard X-ray Radiation of Two Ribbons in a Thermal-Dominated C-Class Flare

TL;DR

This study investigates the asymmetric hard X-ray emission in a thermal-dominated C-class solar flare, revealing that the flare's loop geometry and magnetic field configuration primarily cause the observed emission asymmetry.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of the magnetic and plasma conditions leading to HXR asymmetry in a thermal flare, combining multi-spacecraft observations with magnetic field modeling.

Findings

HXR emission is over 95% thermal in nature.

Asymmetry is mainly due to shorter magnetic loops and weaker magnetic fields at the northern ribbon.

Magnetic field topology and loop length influence electron transport and emission asymmetry.

Abstract

The asymmetry in hard X-ray (HXR) emission at the footpoints (FPs) of flare loops is a ubiquitous feature closely associated with nonthermal electron transport. We analyze the asymmetric HXR radiation at two flare ribbons which is thermal-dominated during a long-duration C4.4 flare that occurred on March 20, 2023, combining multi-view and multi-waveband observations from the ASO-S, SolO, and SDO spacecraft. We find that the H I Ly$\alpha$ emission captures similar features to the He II $\lambda$304 in both light curve and spatio-temporal evolution of a pair of conjugate flare ribbons. The spectra and imaging analysis of the HXR emission, detected by STIX in 4-18 keV, reveal that the two-ribbon flare radiation is thermal dominated by over 95%, and the radiation source mainly concentrates on the northern ribbon, leading to an asymmetric distribution. To understand the underlying reasons for the HXR radiation asymmetry, we extrapolate the magnetic field within the active region using the NLFFF model. For 78% of the magnetic field lines starting from the northern flare ribbon, their lengths from the loop-tops (LTs) to the northern FPs are shorter than those to the southern FPs. For 62% of the field lines, their magnetic field strengths at the southern FPs exceed those at the northern FPs. In addition, considering the larger density, $\approx1.0\times10^{10}$ cm$^{-3}$, of the low-lying flare loops (< 32 Mm), we find the shorter path from the LT to the northern FP enables more electrons to reach the northern FP more easily after collisions with the surrounding plasma. Therefore, in this thermal-dominated C-class flare, the asymmetric location of the flare LT relative to its two FPs plays a dominant role in the HXR radiation asymmetry, while such asymmetry is also slightly influenced by the magnetic mirror effect resulting in larger HXR radiation at the FPs with weaker magnetic strength.