Learning to Steer Markovian Agents under Model Uncertainty
Jiawei Huang, Vinzenz Thoma, Zebang Shen, Heinrich H. Nax, Niao He

TL;DR
This paper develops a model-based reinforcement learning approach to design incentives that steer multi-agent systems towards desired behaviors without prior knowledge of their learning dynamics, focusing on history-dependent strategies under model uncertainty.
Contribution
It introduces a novel non-episodic RL formulation for steering Markovian agents with unknown dynamics, including a new objective and algorithms for history-dependent strategies.
Findings
Theoretical conditions for the existence of steering strategies.
Empirical algorithms effectively learn history-dependent incentives.
Successful empirical evaluation demonstrating approach efficacy.
Abstract
Designing incentives for an adapting population is a ubiquitous problem in a wide array of economic applications and beyond. In this work, we study how to design additional rewards to steer multi-agent systems towards desired policies \emph{without} prior knowledge of the agents' underlying learning dynamics. Motivated by the limitation of existing works, we consider a new and general category of learning dynamics called \emph{Markovian agents}. We introduce a model-based non-episodic Reinforcement Learning (RL) formulation for our steering problem. Importantly, we focus on learning a \emph{history-dependent} steering strategy to handle the inherent model uncertainty about the agents' learning dynamics. We introduce a novel objective function to encode the desiderata of achieving a good steering outcome with reasonable cost. Theoretically, we identify conditions for the existence of…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
- The method introduced in the paper is commended for its intuitive and logical approach. By assuming that the learning dynamics of the agents are Markovian and can be learned in finite steps, the paper effectively simplifies the complex problem of steering under uncertainty. - The paper provides transparency regarding the experimental assumptions detailed in the appendices. Moreover, the experimental setup involves a wide range of learning rate combinations, specifically up to 3^10. - The pap
While I appreciate the application of reinforcement learning (RL) to address the steering problem, balancing exploration and exploitation amidst the uncertainty of agents' learning dynamics, but there are some concerns regarding the paper: - A primary challenge highlighted is the agents' reluctance to disclose their learning dynamics, creating fundamental model uncertainty. The theoretical discussion posits that if the model class $F$ of the agents is identifiable, then an epsilon-steering stra
Strengths: 1. The authors introduce a new objective function that balances the goal of steering agents toward a target policy while minimizing the overall steering cost. 2. The paper provides sufficient conditions under which the proposed steering strategies are effective, ensuring a low gap between target and actual agent behavior and achieving Pareto optimality. 3. The paper includes experimental results in different environments, demonstrating the algorithms' performance under varying model
Weakness: 1. Poor writing: The writing in this paper needs significant improvement; it appears to have been put together in a hurry, making it very difficult to read. As a new research problem, the steering problem has not been well-motivated or clearly formulated, leaving key concepts ambiguous. For example, the definitions of "desired policies" and "desired behaviors" are unclear, and it’s difficult to understand their precise meaning in this context. If we already know the desired policies,
*Conceptual Novelty and Relevance*: The paper introduces an approach to steering agents by focusing on Markovian agents with limited cognitive resources. *Theoretical Contributions*: The authors provide a comprehensive theoretical analysis, including sufficient conditions for achieving low steering gaps and the existence of history-dependent steering strategies. *Algorithmic Development*: The proposed algorithms (belief-state-based steering strategy for small model classes and a First-Explore
This is a solid paper with well-grounded contributions. My primary concern, however, is that the current setting is limited to a tabular MDP with a finite model class. While this simplified setting is acceptable for a theoretical paper, the corresponding experiments appear relatively basic. I am curious about whether the proposed Steering Dynamics framework can be extended effectively to more realistic scenarios (or if the Steering Dynamics framework is helpful in any real-world situation?) invo
Code & Models
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsMachine Learning and Algorithms · Data Stream Mining Techniques · Bayesian Modeling and Causal Inference
MethodsFocus
