Competition of Exchange and Correlation Energies in Two-Dimensional $N$-component Electron Gas Ferromagnetism

TL;DR

This study investigates magnetic phase transitions in a four-component electron gas model, revealing how correlation effects alter the nature of ferromagnetic transitions and providing insights relevant to multilayer graphene systems.

Contribution

The paper introduces a detailed analysis of exchange and correlation energy competition in a four-component electron gas, highlighting the impact of correlation energy on phase transition behavior.

Findings

Hartree-Fock predicts a cascade of density-driven ferromagnetic transitions.

Correlation energy modifies the transition to a single phase transition at higher r_s.

The transition is governed by the balance of exchange and correlation energies.

Abstract

Motivated by recent observations of symmtry broken phases in lightly-doped multilayer graphene, we investigate magnetic phase transitions in a generalized electron gas model with four-component electron spin. This model simplifies the problem with a parabolic dispersion band, abstracting away the details of the graphene band structure to focus solely on the effects of the Coulomb interaction. We report four findings: 1) In the Hartree-Fock approximation, we observe that the paramagnetic state undergoes a sequence of density-driven, first-order phase transitions, progressively depopulating electrons from each spin component until achieving complete polarization within a very narrow density window where $1.2<r_s<2$ ($r_s$ being the electron gas parameter). 2) Further incorporating the correlation energy via the Bohm-Pines random-phase approximation shows that the cascade of transitions obtained within Hartree-Fock approximation is replaced by a single ferromagnetic phase transition at $r_s = 6.12$. 3) The disappearance of cascade is due to the correlation energy difference between the four-component paramagnetic state and symmetry-broken phases, which is nearly an order of magnitude more negative than the corresponding Hartree-Fock energy difference for $1.2 < r_s < 2$. 4) The transition from the paramagnetic state to the fully polarized state at $r_s=6.12$ is governed by the balance between exchange and correlation energies, a competition that cannot be captured by mean-field approximations to models featuring effective (density-dependent) delta-function interactions, such as the Stoner model. We use the insights from our model to comment on the phase diagram of multilayer graphene electron gas.