On the Expressive Power of Sparse Geometric MPNNs
Yonatan Sverdlov, Nadav Dym

TL;DR
This paper investigates the expressive capabilities of sparse geometric message-passing neural networks, demonstrating their ability to distinguish non-isomorphic graphs under certain conditions and introducing a new architecture, EGENNET, that achieves these guarantees.
Contribution
It provides theoretical guarantees for separating geometric graphs with sparse, rotation-equivariant message-passing networks and introduces the EGENNET architecture for practical applications.
Findings
Rotation-equivariant networks can distinguish non-isomorphic graphs when connected.
Invariant features guarantee separation for globally rigid graphs.
EGENNET performs well on synthetic and chemical graph benchmarks.
Abstract
Motivated by applications in chemistry and other sciences, we study the expressive power of message-passing neural networks for geometric graphs, whose node features correspond to 3-dimensional positions. Recent work has shown that such models can separate generic pairs of non-isomorphic geometric graphs, though they may fail to separate some rare and complicated instances. However, these results assume a fully connected graph, where each node possesses complete knowledge of all other nodes. In contrast, often, in application, every node only possesses knowledge of a small number of nearest neighbors. This paper shows that generic pairs of non-isomorphic geometric graphs can be separated by message-passing networks with rotation equivariant features as long as the underlying graph is connected. When only invariant intermediate features are allowed, generic separation is guaranteed for…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
The paper utilizes global rigidity to develop a novel direction for developing geometric graph neural networks. EGenNet achieves state of the art performance and makes significant improvements on a few datasets.
I have two major concerns regarding the submitted work. 1) Incomplete Submission: The paper contains 'TODO' placeholders and formatting issues, indicating it is an unfinished draft. This severely hinders the ability to conduct a thorough and fair review and compromises the integrity of the review process and the conference's high standards. 2) Lack of Consistency and Discussion in Empirical Results: The empirical results lack completeness and coherence. Key sections are marked TODO, and there
1. The paper is clear on addressing the question of expressivity on the specific area of sparse graphs, which is relevant to applications like molecular modeling, where the computational cost of fully connected graphs is prohibitive. 2. The authors provide a theoretical analysis distinguishing the separation power of E-GGNNs and I-GGNNs based on graph connectivity and rigidity, which adds clarity to the strengths and limitations of each approach. 3. The proposed architecture seems to be fairly
- I find the connection of generic matrices with the use cases of graphs complicated. The authors do not show a clear motivation on defining expressivity over generic spaces for the use over graphs. Can the authors motivate better the analysis over generic spaces? What happens in the non-genericity direction? - The tradeoff between efficiency and expressiveness is confusing. It seems that still if we want to achieve maximal expressiveness leads to quadratic complexity (G.2 Section), not having
- Analyzing the expressive power of sparse geometric GNNs is a relevant research direction, closing the gap between theory (where the attention has been mostly on full graphs) and practive (where typically sparse graphs are considered, e.g., via distance cutoffs). - The characterizations for the expressivity of in- and equivariant GNNs are simple and practical, and are therefore relevant to the research community, in my opinion. - The empirical results are quite strong, as EGenNet outperforms pr
Although I understand that the assumption of genericity makes the analysis tractable, this remains a significant limitation. Real-world geometric graphs, particularly in the chemical domain, can exhibit lots of symmetries that cannot be overlooked.
Code & Models
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsFerroelectric and Negative Capacitance Devices · Advanced Memory and Neural Computing · 3D Shape Modeling and Analysis
