Probabilistic Conformal Prediction with Approximate Conditional Validity
Vincent Plassier, Alexander Fishkov, Mohsen Guizani, Maxim Panov, Eric, Moulines

TL;DR
This paper introduces a new probabilistic conformal prediction method that achieves approximate conditional coverage by leveraging estimates of the conditional distribution, improving reliability in heteroscedastic settings.
Contribution
It extends existing conformal methods to provide approximately conditional coverage with theoretical bounds, enhancing prediction set adaptivity and reliability.
Findings
Outperforms existing methods in conditional coverage
Provides non-asymptotic bounds based on total variation distance
Demonstrates effectiveness through extensive simulations
Abstract
We develop a new method for generating prediction sets that combines the flexibility of conformal methods with an estimate of the conditional distribution . Existing methods, such as conformalized quantile regression and probabilistic conformal prediction, usually provide only a marginal coverage guarantee. In contrast, our approach extends these frameworks to achieve approximately conditional coverage, which is crucial for many practical applications. Our prediction sets adapt to the behavior of the predictive distribution, making them effective even under high heteroscedasticity. While exact conditional guarantees are infeasible without assumptions on the underlying data distribution, we derive non-asymptotic bounds that depend on the total variation distance of the conditional distribution and its estimate. Using extensive simulations, we show that our method…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
- The issue of conditional coverage of conformal prediction methods is of particular interest in CP community. They expand the ideas of using an estimation of conditional coverage to enhance the covariate-conditional performance of CP to the more general setting of multi-dimensional prediction tasks. - They also provide theoretical guarantees on the relation between the quality of the conditional distribution estimation and the improvements in the conditional coverage property of CP, which was a
- In general, the whole line of work based on estimations of conditional density suffers from the curse of dimensionality (covariate dimension). Therefore, it is important to see some empirical evaluations of the proposed method on high dimensional tasks (in particular image classification), even if it doesn't work very well, it helps the follow-up works with having a more accurate understanding of your method. Another interesting experiment to see is a synthetic regression task that you can dir
1. the underlying approach of estimating the conditional distribution via sampling and proposing the conformal set using these samples (to my knowledge) is unique to this paper 2. This paper has very nice asymptotic guarantees of performance under different underly data distributions 3. The approach is very simple and applicable, making it generally useful in many fields. 4. The empirical validation is very impressive
1. Some of the figures are not accessible. It is difficult to see for someone who is red-green colorblind. This includes Figure 1. 2. Some of the presentation of the theoretical ideas, especially on page 6, is difficult to parse. Better formatting would increase readability.
This paper provides a specific approach to leverage information from the conditional distribution to improve conditional coverage. Besides estimating conditional distributions directly, the authors also consider alternatives using a conditional generative model when identifying HPDs is challenging.
1. The paper's writing could be improved, particularly in terms of clarity and presentation. For example, the literature review lacks clarity, and could benefit from a more comprehensive and topic-oriented discussion of related work. 2. Regarding the experimental section, it is noted that several key baselines from existing literature have been overlooked. Additionally, it seems that the superiority of CP² in terms of worst-slab coverage is not particularly evident comparing with CQR/CQR2 in Fi
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsNeural Networks and Applications
