cryoSPHERE: Single-particle heterogeneous reconstruction from cryo EM
Gabriel Ducrocq, Lukas Grunewald, Sebastian Westenhoff, Fredrik, Lindsten

TL;DR
cryoSPHERE is a deep learning method that leverages nominal structures like AlphaFold to reconstruct multiple conformations of proteins from noisy cryo-EM data, advancing the understanding of protein dynamics.
Contribution
introduces cryoSPHERE, a novel deep learning approach that segments and rigidly moves parts of a protein to recover its conformational heterogeneity from cryo-EM images.
Findings
outperforms current state-of-the-art in noisy conditions
successfully reconstructs multiple conformations from synthetic datasets
demonstrates effectiveness on real cryo-EM datasets
Abstract
The three-dimensional structure of proteins plays a crucial role in determining their function. Protein structure prediction methods, like AlphaFold, offer rapid access to a protein structure. However, large protein complexes cannot be reliably predicted, and proteins are dynamic, making it important to resolve their full conformational distribution. Single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is a powerful tool for determining the structures of large protein complexes. Importantly, the numerous images of a given protein contain underutilized information about conformational heterogeneity. These images are very noisy projections of the protein, and traditional methods for cryo-EM reconstruction are limited to recovering only one or a few consensus conformations. In this paper, we introduce cryoSPHERE, which is a deep learning method that uses a nominal protein structure (e.g.,…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
Instead of finding the deformation for each residue, cryoSPHERE learns a segmentation of the amino acid or nucleotide chains and deforms the segment to fit the heterogenous cryo-EM data. This is indeed a valid assumption in many cases especially for large complexes like the spliceosome (EMPIAR-10180).
Major: 1. CryoSPHERE uses an atomic model as the reference and formulate the conformational heterogeneity in cryo-EM dataset as the deformation of the segments of the reference model. In finding the optimal segments, the approach is similar to what used in e2gmm, where a GMM with N_{segm} components is fitted. This segmentation result is then used in a cryoSTAR/DynaMight-like setting, replacing the regularization losses and compute predicted projections to compare with the particle images. The a
The work is of high quality and overall very well-written. I’d like to highlight the following strong points of the paper: - The authors seem very well aware of the difficulties atomistic models have in terms of the optimisation landscape and address the problem adequately by regularising while keeping sequential information intact - The authors give useful biological remarks such as that their methods seems to recover domains, which is useful to know as a practitioner - The authors show that th
There is one main weak point in the paper in my regard: - The authors do not address limitations of their method very thoroughly: - whether or not their method is able to overcome poor initialisation of the initial structure S_0. This is one of the major risks of working with (pseudo)-atomistic models as shown in works such as DynaMight (Schwab et al. 2024) - Whether or not local physical information such as bond lengths between atoms at the boundaries of the segments is preserved. This
1. The approach of learning to decompose the protein’s amino acid chain into segments to represent various conformations is novel. 2. The interpretability of moving part is highly beneficial for practitioners, offering a clearer understanding of conformational dynamics.
1. No meaningful improvements were observed over CryoStar - Figures 3, 12, 13: It’s unclear what meaningful differences exist compared to CryoStar. - Figures 14, 21: There doesn’t appear to be a significant difference between CryoStar and CryoSphere (CryoStar may even appear better). - Figure 29: It would be great to compare CryoStar with CryoSphere rather than with CryoDRGN. 2. Should change Figure 6: - Instead of showing only CryoDRGN results and G.T, a comparison with CryoSTAR
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsAdvanced Electron Microscopy Techniques and Applications · Electron and X-Ray Spectroscopy Techniques
MethodsAlphaFold
