Thermophotovoltaic performance metrics and techno-economics: efficiency vs. power density

TL;DR

This paper unifies efficiency and power density into a single techno-economic metric for thermophotovoltaics, analyzing how different system costs influence the prioritization of these metrics to optimize cost-effectiveness.

Contribution

It introduces a novel combined metric based on LCOE, providing guidance on optimizing TPV design by balancing efficiency and power density according to system costs.

Findings

High heating costs favor efficiency optimization.

High cell costs favor power density optimization.

Improving spectral control and surface reflectance significantly reduces LCOE.

Abstract

Thermophotovoltaics (TPV) are a promising new approach for converting heat to electricity. Their performance is primarily characterized by two metrics: efficiency and power density. While recent works have shown high efficiency, it is important to understand how both of these metrics impact the techno-economics of a TPV system as efforts to commercialize the technology advance. In this work, we develop the first unification of efficiency and power density into a single techno-economic metric based on the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE). We find that the LCOE can be broken into two parts: heating cost, including infrastructure and inputs for providing heat to the TPV cells, and cell cost, the capital cost of the TPV cells. We show that systems with high heating costs should prioritize TPV efficiency, while systems with high cell costs should prioritize power density. We then develop a model to identify the most impactful cell properties in improving the important performance metric and reducing system LCOE. Namely, improving spectral control with increased back-surface reflectance is the most effective to reduce LCOE in systems with high infrastructural costs, while increasing the view factor and reducing front-surface reflectance are most critical in systems with high TPV cell cost. Improving just one or two of these properties can reduce the LCOE by 25-75%, reaching competitive values ~ 8 cents/kWh-e, less than the average cost of electricity in the US. This study thus elucidates which TPV performance metric is more important for system technoeconomics and how to maximize it.