Dark energy with a shift-symmetric scalar field: obstacles, loophole hunting and dead ends

TL;DR

This paper investigates the viability of shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theories, specifically Kinetic Gravity Braiding, as models for dark energy, analyzing stability conditions and identifying fundamental obstacles and potential loopholes.

Contribution

It provides a detailed stability analysis of shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theories and derives explicit relations between covariant theories and Effective Field Theory parameters up to arbitrary perturbation order.

Findings

No stable dark energy solutions exploiting the loophole are found.

Higher-order interactions pose fundamental obstacles to stability.

Explicit parameter mappings between theories are provided.

Abstract

We discuss the possibility of a scalar field being the fundamental description of dark energy. We focus on shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theories since this symmetry potentially avoids some fine-tuning problems. We also restrict attention to theories satisfying that the propagation speed of gravitational waves is equal to the speed of light. These considerations lead us to investigate shift-symmetric Kinetic Gravity Braiding theories. Analysing the stability of scalar linear perturbations, we discuss the conditions that seems to be necessary to describe (super) accelerated cosmic expansion without introducing instabilities. However, it has been previously established that the linearised analysis does not guarantee the stability of this non-canonical scalar theory, as potentially dangerous interactions between dark energy fluctuations and tensor perturbations (essentially gravitational waves) appear at a higher order in perturbation theory. Indeed, although we shall point out that the standard proof of absence of dark energy stable braiding models due to this interaction has a possible way-out, we find general arguments suggesting that there are no dark energy stable solutions that can exploit this loophole. Thus, we discuss future research directions for finding viable fundamental descriptions of dark energy. We also provide a dictionary between the covariant version of the scalar field theory and that of the Effective Field Theory approach, explicitly computing the parameters in the latter formalism in terms of the functions appearing in the covariant version, and its derivatives. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time these expressions are explicitly obtained up-to arbitrary order in perturbation theory.